Seahawks All-Duds Team

Hawknballs":38z0iozb said:

Trrrroy":38z0iozb said:

QB- Charlie Whitehurst at QB for sure.
WR- Housh
RB- Julius Jones
P- Ryan Plackemier
K- Walsh

Click to expand...

I'll tell you one reason why it's NOT Whitehurst "for sure" or even at all -

If Charlie Whitehurst doesn't beat the Rams 16-6 in week 17 of the 2010 season, the rams win the Division, and we don't go to the playoffs.

Without Charlie Whitehurst there is no huge upset of the defending champ Saints.

Without Charlie Whitehurst, there is no Beastquake.

Click to expand...

And for that same reason, I will never add Blair Walsh to this list. If he were competent, the Hawks likely are 11-5 that season and make the playoffs. If that is the case, the status quo is maintained and Bevell, and more importantly Cable, are retained.

Hawknballs":2ay8umd3 said:

Trrrroy":2ay8umd3 said:

QB- Charlie Whitehurst at QB for sure.
WR- Housh
RB- Julius Jones
P- Ryan Plackemier
K- Walsh

Click to expand...

I'll tell you one reason why it's NOT Whitehurst "for sure" or even at all -

If Charlie Whitehurst doesn't beat the Rams 16-6 in week 17 of the 2010 season, the rams win the Division, and we don't go to the playoffs.

Without Charlie Whitehurst there is no huge upset of the defending champ Saints.

Without Charlie Whitehurst, there is no Beastquake.

Click to expand...

That wasn't Whitehurst on the "BEASTQUAKE" play, that was Matthew Hustlebutt.

How about the entire 1999 draft class...


Round Pick # Overall Name Position College
1 22 22 Lamar King Defensive end Saginaw Valley State
3 16 77 Brock Huard Quarterback Washington
3 21 82 Karsten Bailey Wide receiver Auburn
4 20 115 Antonio Cochran Defensive end Georgia
5 7 140 Floyd Wedderburn Offensive tackle Penn State
5 19 152 Charlie Rogers Running back Georgia Tech
6 1 170 Steve Johnson Cornerback Tennessee

Sorry, thought this was another uniform thread...

scutterhawk":2rfmi4ph said:

Hawknballs":2rfmi4ph said:

Trrrroy":2rfmi4ph said:

QB- Charlie Whitehurst at QB for sure.
WR- Housh
RB- Julius Jones
P- Ryan Plackemier
K- Walsh

Click to expand...

I'll tell you one reason why it's NOT Whitehurst "for sure" or even at all -

If Charlie Whitehurst doesn't beat the Rams 16-6 in week 17 of the 2010 season, the rams win the Division, and we don't go to the playoffs.

Without Charlie Whitehurst there is no huge upset of the defending champ Saints.

Without Charlie Whitehurst, there is no Beastquake.

Click to expand...

That wasn't Whitehurst on the "BEASTQUAKE" play, that was Matthew Hustlebutt.

Click to expand...

He said the Hawks wouldn't have been in the playoffs for the Beastquake to happen, not that Whitehurst played in the game.

Yea, I remember, Mike Williams came into camp like
40 lbs over weight the next season. I think he sat home
And ate donuts all off season.

Matt Flynn

Tarvaris Jackson
David Greene
Ruben Rodriguez
Gale Gilbert
Steve Myer
Malik McDowell
Anton Palepoi
Andre Hines

Jerhawk":1mmumq9s said:

QB - David Greene
RB - Julius Jones / Robert Turbin
WR - TJ Houshmandzadeh
TE - Marcus Pollard
OT - Robert Gallery
OG - James Carpenter

DB - Kelly Jennings / Cary Williams
Safety - Brian Russell
LB - Aaron Curry
DE - Patrick Kerney

Click to expand...

Gotta question the Kerney nomination. His first year in Seattle he led the NFC in sacks. The next year he injured his shoulder, never really recovered, and retired after his 3rd year as a Hawk admitting he could not play like he needed to. Dud...?

hawkfan68":26k7rbcx said:

Tarvaris Jackson
David Greene
Ruben Rodriguez
Gale Gilbert
Steve Myer
Malik McDowell
Anton Palepoi
Andre Hines

Click to expand...

Myer wasn't bad, he never got a chance to show he could be good, remember he got hit and his neck broken a lot like David Sims.

Grahamhawker":29ojqo05 said:

Jerhawk":29ojqo05 said:

QB - David Greene
RB - Julius Jones / Robert Turbin
WR - TJ Houshmandzadeh
TE - Marcus Pollard
OT - Robert Gallery
OG - James Carpenter

DB - Kelly Jennings / Cary Williams
Safety - Brian Russell
LB - Aaron Curry
DE - Patrick Kerney

Click to expand...

Gotta question the Kerney nomination. His first year in Seattle he led the NFC in sacks. The next year he injured his shoulder, never really recovered, and retired after his 3rd year as a Hawk admitting he could not play like he needed to. Dud...?

Click to expand...

He was also an all-pro that year, and really, the entire team fell off a cliff in 2008, not just Kerney. It's hard to soar like an eagle when you're surrounded by turkeys.

Malik McDowell

I started watching Seahawk football in 2002 so I’ll start from there . I’ll make my selections by the guy either being straight poop or miserably failing expectations .

QB - Whitehurst ( he was awful )

FB Heath Evans - just wasn’t Mack Strong

WR - Mike Williams ( after his contract signing ) . Deion Branch . And don’t forget Percy Harvin !

TE - Jeremy Stevens - so much talent , couldn’t catch anything .

OL - Tim Ruskel ( letting Hutchinson leave lmao )

DL - Grant Winstrom ( former Ram , big expectations but just too old already )

LB - Aaron Curry

CB - Cary Williams


Honestly when I think back to since when I started watching Seahawk Football , we haven’t had many losing seasons and Luckily our All Time Greats list would look prettty amazing :irishdrinkers:

What??? no BOZ?

Leee-roy":2mc9lodj said:

What??? no BOZ?

Click to expand...

Boz played over 30 years ago. The question was the last 15 years.

Maulbert":1k0m0qer said:

Leee-roy":1k0m0qer said:

What??? no BOZ?

Click to expand...

Boz played over 30 years ago. The question was the last 15 years.

Click to expand...

Yeah because to many don't know anything about the Seahawks before Mike Holmgren was here. All Seahawks Duds should mean just that ALL.

chris98251":37id1dmu said:

Maulbert":37id1dmu said:

Leee-roy":37id1dmu said:

What??? no BOZ?

Click to expand...

Boz played over 30 years ago. The question was the last 15 years.

Click to expand...

Yeah because to many don't know anything about the Seahawks before Mike Holmgren was here. All Seahawks Duds should mean just that ALL.

Click to expand...

That's the way I read it as well. And I mentioned Bosworth.

NorthDallas40oz":br2le2ii said:

How about the entire 1999 draft class...


Round Pick # Overall Name Position College
1 22 22 Lamar King Defensive end Saginaw Valley State
3 16 77 Brock Huard Quarterback Washington
3 21 82 Karsten Bailey Wide receiver Auburn
4 20 115 Antonio Cochran Defensive end Georgia
5 7 140 Floyd Wedderburn Offensive tackle Penn State
5 19 152 Charlie Rogers Running back Georgia Tech
6 1 170 Steve Johnson Cornerback Tennessee

Click to expand...

Charlie Rogers was good return man. The rest, all serviceable.

Largent80":2lonokxf said:

Koren Robinson.

Click to expand...

man that's a whole other level of disappointing.... He had all the skills but could not stay out of trouble!

WmHBonney":qa4c55pj said:

Malik McDowell

Click to expand...

Yep.. he has to be on the list.