Niner fans have no right complaining about calls

seahawksny · Dec 14, 2014

I didn't agree with the roughing the passer call on Wilson, and I'd probably be upset too if it were the opposite.

However, what I saw today is what I've seen the last 4 years in Santa Clara and that is they are awarded 30-45 yards a game in non unsportsmanlike conduct calls against their coach.

In baseball, a manager is thrown from game arguing to the point that harbaugh does.

In basketball, technicals before eventual ejection occur at when coaches blow their top the way he does.

Why doesn't the same apply for football? No other coach is given the special treatment he gets.

taco40 · Dec 14, 2014

seahawksny":3vnvien2 said:
I didnt agree with the roughing the passer call on wilson, and I'd probably be upset too if it were the opposite.

However, what I saw today is what I've seen the last 4 years in Santa clara and that is they are awarded 30-45 yards a game in non unsportsmanlike conduct calls against their coach
.
in baseball, a manager is thrown from game arguing to the point that harbaugh does

In basketball, technicals before eventual ejection occur at when coaches blow their top the way he does.

Why doesn't the same apply for football? No other coach is given the special treatment he gets

It might be that he is so irrelevant that even the refs just laugh him off. :les:

Seanhawk · Dec 14, 2014

This is a flimsy argument. Unsportsmanlike penalties are very rare in football period.

Edit: on coaches they're rare.

jkitsune · Dec 14, 2014

Coaches aren't flagged in football for arguing. It's no different for any other coach.

seahawksny · Dec 14, 2014

Seanhawk":2tcym0w1 said:
This is a flimsy argument. Unsportsmanlike penalties are very rare in football period.

Not true
they are called against players all the time
same standard should apply

jkitsune · Dec 14, 2014

But it doesn't. Harbaugh doesn't get any special treatment. I'm not sure where you're getting the idea that other coaches would get flagged for Harbaugh's level of arguing.

seahawksny · Dec 14, 2014

jkitsune":3dhbhxis said:
Coaches aren't flagged in football for arguing. It's no different for any other coach.

They should be , cause frankly I think he's a disgrace to the game. John McEnroe of the 2000s

jkitsune · Dec 14, 2014

seahawksny":31v7b59o said:
jkitsune":31v7b59o said:

Coaches aren't flagged in football for arguing. It's no different for any other coach.

Click to expand...

They should be , cause frankly I think he's a disgrace to the game. John McEnroe of the 2000s

OK, but your original argument is that Harbaugh is getting special treatment. He's not. You just don't like the rules.

seahawksny · Dec 14, 2014

jkitsune":e6nbihfm said:
But it doesn't. Harbaugh doesn't get any special treatment. I'm not sure where you're getting the idea that other coaches would get flagged for Harbaugh's level of arguing.

You don't know that. Nobody bitches like he does. Thank goodness

Hawkpower · Dec 14, 2014

seahawksny":1f6e3e2u said:
jkitsune":1f6e3e2u said:

But it doesn't. Harbaugh doesn't get any special treatment. I'm not sure where you're getting the idea that other coaches would get flagged for Harbaugh's level of arguing.

Click to expand...

You don't know that. Nobody bitches like he does. Thank goodness

Actually, we do know that.

No coaches get flagged, and plenty throw fits on the sideline. Did you watch the Chipster last week?

Time to go ahead and abandon this argument.

therealjohncarlson · Dec 14, 2014

seahawksny":156me21c said:
jkitsune":156me21c said:

But it doesn't. Harbaugh doesn't get any special treatment. I'm not sure where you're getting the idea that other coaches would get flagged for Harbaugh's level of arguing.

Click to expand...

You don't know that. Nobody bitches like he does. Thank goodness

Solid argument. Makes sense

seahawksny · Dec 14, 2014

jkitsune":oo2zh1f0 said:
seahawksny":oo2zh1f0 said:

jkitsune":oo2zh1f0 said:

Coaches aren't flagged in football for arguing. It's no different for any other coach.

Click to expand...

They should be , cause frankly I think he's a disgrace to the game. John McEnroe of the 2000s

Click to expand...

OK, but your original argument is that Harbaugh is getting special treatment. He's not. You just don't like the rules.

Me not liking the rules is irrelevant. Penalties like unsportsmanlike conduct are at the discretion of the officials. Like balls and strikes. No defined limits, they can be called at anytime for any reason.
And they SHOULD be called on him, regardless if it's accepted or not.

therealjohncarlson · Dec 14, 2014

seahawksny":3sjccdpk said:
jkitsune":3sjccdpk said:

seahawksny":3sjccdpk said:

jkitsune":3sjccdpk said:

Coaches aren't flagged in football for arguing. It's no different for any other coach.

Click to expand...

They should be , cause frankly I think he's a disgrace to the game. John McEnroe of the 2000s

Click to expand...

OK, but your original argument is that Harbaugh is getting special treatment. He's not. You just don't like the rules.

Click to expand...

Me not liking the rules is irrelevant. Penalties like unsportsmanlike conduct are at the discretion of the officials. Like balls and strikes. No defined limits, they can be called at anytime for any reason.
And they SHOULD be called on him, regardless if it's accepted or not.

Ok but your argument that harbaugh gets special treatment has absolutely no basis in reality

Hawkpower · Dec 14, 2014

seahawksny":dz1qsj9m said:
jkitsune":dz1qsj9m said:

seahawksny":dz1qsj9m said:

jkitsune":dz1qsj9m said:

Coaches aren't flagged in football for arguing. It's no different for any other coach.

Click to expand...

They should be , cause frankly I think he's a disgrace to the game. John McEnroe of the 2000s

Click to expand...

OK, but your original argument is that Harbaugh is getting special treatment. He's not. You just don't like the rules.

Click to expand...

Me not liking the rules is irrelevant. Penalties like unsportsmanlike conduct are at the discretion of the officials. Like balls and strikes. No defined limits, they can be called at anytime for any reason.
And they SHOULD be called on him, regardless if it's accepted or not.

Fine.

But they arent. Ever.

Therefore your argument about SF getting special treatment is null and void.

RichNhansom · Dec 14, 2014

I could care less if they don't like the officiating. I didn't like our last game were we were called for 14 penalties while they were called for 3. They had gained more yards from our penalties than their own passes.

Last year the only reason we didn't sweep them was because a blatantly wrong call the officials deliberately changed what the call was simply so we couldn't challenge it and that bogus call prevented a Crabtree fumble recovered by us from being reviewed and giving us the ball. They scored 3 on that drive and only won by 2 and we had one less possession. If they get that call right we bet them in candlestick and sweep them last year.

Seanhawk · Dec 14, 2014

seahawksny":j9fc6mka said:
Seanhawk":j9fc6mka said:

This is a flimsy argument. Unsportsmanlike penalties are very rare in football period.

Click to expand...

Not true
they are called against players all the time
same standard should apply

I meant on coaches.

RiverDog · Dec 14, 2014

RichNhansom":23rmsu7x said:
I could care less if they don't like the officiating. I didn't like our last game were we were called for 14 penalties while they were called for 3. They had gained more yards from our penalties than their own passes.

Last year the only reason we didn't sweep them was because a blatantly wrong call the officials deliberately changed what the call was simply so we couldn't challenge it and that bogus call prevented a Crabtree fumble recovered by us from being reviewed and giving us the ball. They scored 3 on that drive and only won by 2 and we had one less possession. If they get that call right we bet them in candlestick and sweep them last year.

I disagreed with the roughing the passer call, but the network guys made wAAAAy too big of a deal out of it. To hear them tell it, you would have thought that the entire game hinged on that one call. Although it's impossible to tell for sure, I got the sense that a 6 point lead would have stood up just as well as 10 points did.

I'd also remind Niner fans that they got away with a clear PI in the first half that cost us at least 3 points.

Bigpumpkin · Dec 14, 2014

Sometimes you get the breaks...sometimes you don't. :3-1:

lucky49 · Dec 14, 2014

this thread is on webzone-tier

jkitsune · Dec 14, 2014

lucky49":299b5i41 said:
this thread is on webzone-tier

Quite true. It has gotten amusing though, at least.

Niner fans have no right complaining about calls

Active member

Member

New member

New member

Active member

New member

Active member

New member

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Active member

New member

Well-known member

Active member

New member

New member

Similar threads