ImTheScientist":29ummb5u said:
SacHawk2.0":29ummb5u said:
ImTheScientist":29ummb5u said:
Not to rain on the parade but the NFL today is much different than the NFL Of 2003.
Not really. It's not like 2003 was the 70's.
2013 Leaders
http://www.pro-football-reference.com/y ... eaders.htm
2003 Leaders
http://www.pro-football-reference.com/y ... eaders.htm
Look at those lists .... not sure you can say they are even close to similar. Manning lead in passing with 4,267 yards....he would have finished 9th (almost 10th) last year with that same number. Wilson's 26 TDs would have ranked him 3rd in the NFL in 2003. In 2003 only one QB had a passer raiting of over 100. In 2013 7 did.
Im likely one of the biggest Wilson fan's on this forum and have been since before he was even drafted but Im not sure I would make that comparison.
http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/in ... +%2Bwilson
Except even compared with today Rw is an Elite top 10 QB, the point was even today those QBs are considered Elite and yet their stats are not even close to RWs.
Maybe this will help for today qbs mind you I did not do this someone else did but it is pretty good and the stats are right and these are based on career numbers or avg per season
Completion Percentage
1) Manning = 65.5%
2) Wilson = 63.6%
3) Brady = 63.4%
4) Luck = 57%
Yards Per Pass Attempt
1) Wilson = 8.1
2) Manning = 7.7
3) Brady = 7.5
4) Luck = 6.8
Passer Rating
1) Wilson = 100.6
2) Manning = 97.2
3) Brady = 95.7
4) Luck = 81.5
Touchdown/Interception Ratio
1) Wilson = 2.74
2) Brady = 2.7
3) Manning = 2.24
4) Luck = 1.7
Passing Touchdowns Per Season Average
1) Manning = 30.69
2) Wilson = 26
3) Brady = 25.64
4) Luck = 23
Passing Yards Per Season Average
1) Luck = 4098
2) Manning = 4059
3) Brady = 3510
4) Wilson = 3238
Rushing Yards Per Season Average
1) Wilson = 514
2) Luck = 316
3) Brady = 55
4) Manning = 44
Passing + Rushing Yards Per Game Average
1) Luck = 276
2) Manning = 257
3) Wilson = 234
4) Brady = 222
Career Win %
1) Brady = 76.5%
2) Wilson = 75.7%
3) Manning = 67.7%
4) Luck = 65.7%
Total Super Bowl Wins
1) Brady = 3
2) Wilson = 1
3) Manning = 1
4) Luck = 0
Super Bowl Win %
1) Wilson = 100%
2) Brady = 60%
3) Manning = 33%
4) Luck = N/A
Super Bowl Wins Per Season%
1) Wilson = 50%
2) Brady = 21.4%
3) Manning = 6.25%
4) Luck = 0%
TOTAL 1ST PLACE RANKINGS:
1) Wilson = 6
2) Brady = 2
3) Manning = 2
4) Luck = 2
TOTAL 2ND PLACE RANKINGS:
1) Wilson = 4
2) Manning = 4
3) Brady = 3
4) Luck = 1
TOTAL 3RD PLACE RANKINGS:
1) Brady = 6
2) Manning = 5
3) Wilson = 1
4) Luck = 0
TOTAL 4TH PLACE RANKINGS:
1) Luck = 9
2) Wilson = 1
3) Brady = 1
4) Manning = 1
CONCLUSION:
When comparing all 4 of these QB's Wilson appears to be the best so far.
If we apply the scientifically fool-proof scoring system used in Mario Kart for the Super Nintendo the scoring would be as follows:
1st Place = 9 Points
2nd Place = 6 Points
3rd Place = 3 Points
4th Place = 1 Point
FINAL RANKINGS:
1) Wilson = 82 Points
2) Manning = 58 Points
3) Brady = 55 Points
4) Luck = 33 Points
