I think we need to talk about Wilson V Luck for a change

For a change? Wilson v Luck has been a recurring topic of conversation around here since the day Wilson was drafted.

I like both but I love me some Wilson. I wouldn't trade Wilson for Luck in other words.

SeatownJay":jimboe31 said:

For a change? Wilson v Luck has been a recurring topic of conversation around here since the day Wilson was drafted.

Click to expand...

Obvious sarcasm...to most

Hawk Finn":21tlf9w7 said:

SeatownJay":21tlf9w7 said:

For a change? Wilson v Luck has been a recurring topic of conversation around here since the day Wilson was drafted.

Click to expand...

Obvious sarcasm...to most

Click to expand...

Exactly.

Was hilarious to watch Bayless argue this point today with Steven A. and Eric Allen. Yes i watch that garbage, don't judge...

SeatownJay":3qyi6rb0 said:

For a change? Wilson v Luck has been a recurring topic of conversation around here since the day Wilson was drafted.

Click to expand...

:sarcasm_on: :sarcasm_off:

Already been discussed today on ESPN. It's been settled.... Tim Hasselbeck the lesser of the Hass bros stated Luck is far superior. No contest due to lack of supporting talent. End of discussion. That guy from Denver who said he'd take RW knows nothing since he only plays the game but as a corner NOT a qb like Tim Hasselhoff.

He obviously never talked about Lucks standout WR corps or the fact Luck is allowed to inflate his stats by winging it unlike RW in Seattle.

One of the reasons I get so annoyed with the supporting cast argument is how you can apply it to other QBs.

Joe Montana: "too short, arm too weak" to play in the NFL. Third round draft pick. Playing in a system ideal for his skillset. Played with a couple of future Hall of Famers on his defense. One of the Super Bowl years they had 4 members of the secondary in the Pro Bowl. Throwing to Jerry Rice, the greatest receiver to strap on cleats (well, except for Largent) and arguably the best football player of all time at any position. Handed off to Roger Craig, a Hall of Fame nominee.

Yet no one argues that Montana was just a product of the team and not one of the reasons for their success.

Retain Wilson. Good luck, Luck.

Chris Harris, CB for the Denver Broncos:

"He's the best quarterback we've played so far," Harris said of Wilson. "I don't know why they keep saying Andrew Luck is better than him. He's not better than Russell Wilson."

Click to expand...

Broncos played the Colts in Week 1.

Russ Willstrong":14v76brl said:

Already been discussed today on ESPN. It's been settled.... Tim Hasselbeck the lesser of the Hass bros stated Luck is far superior. No contest due to lack of supporting talent. End of discussion. That guy from Denver who said he'd take RW knows nothing since he only plays the game but as a corner NOT a qb like Tim Hasselhoff.

He obviously never talked about Lucks standout WR corps or the fact Luck is allowed to inflate his stats by winging it unlike RW in Seattle.

Click to expand...

Or that the holes he continually digs himself out of are mostly self dug.

This article comes after Luck posts a MONSTER game (against Jacksonville). Goofy timing.

kearly":gtbhdlon said:

This article comes after Luck posts a MONSTER game (against Jacksonville). Goofy timing.

Click to expand...

With a "jags" grain of salt, though. Or plenty of caveats, asterisks, etc.

If you recall, Wilson also had a 4-touchdown game against the Jaguars last year.

Im done talking about Luck now...ALL I care about is how this guy plays...no other qb id rather have than this guy

I don't get our tireless infatuation with this debate.

Why can't both QB's be REALLY good? Why do we have to pick sides? "Better" is a nebulous word that cannot be quantified, so why do we keep trying?

Both QB's are awesome and will be awesome for a long time, so let's move on and just be happy we've got one of the two best young QB's in the league that literally EVERY other team wishes they had.

7-0 vs "elite" QB's. So WHO is actually elite?.....

And Sgt. I would say it is much sweeter for us since we got Wilson in the 3rd round and Luck was #1 overall.

Largent80":293wynb2 said:

7-0 vs "elite" QB's. So WHO is actually elite?.....

Click to expand...

"YOUR DEFENSE!"
-Saints, Patriots, Broncos, and Packers fans.

Wilson is not 7-0 against the elite.

The Seahawks are.

Tech Worlds":3oujn6rd said:

Wilson is not 7-0 against the elite.

The Seahawks are.

Click to expand...

ARRRRRrrrrrrrrrrrggghhh.