Top 10 QBs Today: Wilson #2

Using the criteria of mobility, arm strength, accuracy, line of scrimmage, not turning the ball over, clutch (game winning drives and winning big games), and leadership here are my most Talented QBs today:

1) Aaron Rogers
2) Russell Wilson
3) Andrew Luck
4) Drew Brees
5) Tom Brady
6) Phillip Rivers
7) Peyton Manning
8) Matthew Stafford
9) Cam Newton
10) Colin Kaepernick

Peyton is lower then expected because of mobility, arm strength, and not being clutch.

What are your thoughts? Do you agree? Disagree?

Kind of based what I've seen from this season thus far:

1. Manning
2. Ryan
3. Rivers
4. Wilson
5. Brees
6. Luck
7. Rodgers
8. Cutler
9. Rothlesberger
10. Brady

1. Christy Pounder
2. Tom Tivo
3. Barry Tedwater
4. Gedo Smith
5. Roger Griffiths
6. Bryan Fitzpatrick
7. Jonny "mama" Mancini aka Jimmy Baseball
8. Chief Security Officer Worf, son of Mogh
9. Davis Austin
32. Colin Kaepernik

Hawknballs":2f1g90oq said:

2. Tom Tivo

Click to expand...

Win.

Hawknballs":3rr15ild said:

1. Christy Pounder
2. Tom Tivo
3. Barry Tedwater
4. Gedo Smith
5. Roger Griffiths
6. Bryan Fitzpatrick
7. Jonny "mama" Mancini aka Jimmy Baseball
8. Chief Security Officer Worf, son of Mogh
9. Davis Austin
32. Colin Kaepernik

Click to expand...

Haha! This is excellent.

Pandion Haliaetus":3iekrb4u said:

Kind of based what I've seen from this season thus far:

1. Manning
2. Ryan
3. Rivers
4. Wilson
5. Brees
6. Luck
7. Rodgers
8. Cutler
9. Rothlesberger
10. Brady

Click to expand...

Edit:

1. Manning
2. Ryan
3. Rivers
4. Wilson
5. Brees
6. Luck
7. Rodgers
8. Cutler
9. Cousins
10. Foles
11. Rothlisberger
12. Brady
13. Newton
14. Flacco
15. Kaepernick
16. Dalton


I think this is hard to argue, and yes right now Wilson is playing like an elite QB.

I can't see how Kaepernick makes anybody's top 10 when his team is 1-2 and he's ranked in the middle teens in efficiency. What makes him better than Nick Foles or Andy Dalton, who's teams are 3-0 with efficiency ratings higher than Krapperdick?

Top three in no particular order would be Russel, Rivers, Manning. I might give the nod to Rivers, as his team completely revolves around him (much like Manning) and he played much better than Manning against the toughest D out there. His team has also lost a bunch to injuries and are still winning. Remove a flukey high snap and they might be 3-0.

Most of the other QBs have played some crappy teams, so they all belong below those three.