Who would you be OK with trading Sherman for??

irocdave · Apr 9, 2017

This hasn't happened, may happen, but hasn't. Who would you be OK with in return for a trade with Sherman?

I would like to see #25 stay with the hawks for a couple more years, but it seems it isn't up to us fans.

What if Dallas offers up a premium O lineman, like 2 time all pro left tackle Tyrone Smith and a 2018 draft pick?

Seems like the salary is workable.

http://www.spotrac.com/nfl/dallas-cowbo ... mith-7724/

Dallas is desperate for a corner as well. RS checks every box for Jerry, I can really see this happening with the cowboys.

Pie Romania · Apr 9, 2017

irocdave":h5qd2c4k said:
This hasn't happened, may happen, but hasn't. Who would you be OK with in return for a trade with Sherman?

I would like to see #25 stay with the hawks for a couple more years, but it seems it isn't up to us fans.

What if Dallas offers up a premium O lineman, like 2 time all pro left tackle Tyrone Smith and a 2018 draft pick?

Seems like the salary is workable.

http://www.spotrac.com/nfl/dallas-cowbo ... mith-7724/

Dallas is desperate for a corner as well. RS checks every box for Jerry, I can really see this happening with the cowboys.

Smith is still young. No way Dallas does that under any circumstance at such a difficult position to find superior talent these days. They would also have to eat nearly 26 MILLION in dead money, so yeah, never happening.

Edit: And with that dead cap hit, the Cowboys would lose 17.1 million in cap space that they don't have. Add Sherman to that? LOL

stang233 · Apr 9, 2017

Sherman and our 3rd for leonard Williams and a 1st

hawkfan68 · Apr 9, 2017

Sherman and 3rd round pick to the Bucs for Mike Evans

DJrmb · Apr 10, 2017

stang233":26jb7c90 said:
Sherman and our 3rd for leonard Williams and a 1st

I've been thinking about something like this with the Jets. Probably couldn't pry away Williams unfortunately, but I think they would jump at something involving Sheldon Richardson (they've been trying to trade him because they can't afford to keep him after this year). I know he's only under contract for 1 year but it's at a decent price and we could probably afford to franchise him if we wanted the following year or let him walk and get an additional 3rd round pick or maybe even work out an extension. Adding Richardson to Avril, Bennett, and Clark would probably vault our Defensive line to best in the NFL or close. Maybe even be a better D-line than the 2013 group.

Richardson their 2nd and 3rd - for - Sherman and our 3rd.

ctrcat · Apr 10, 2017

DJrmb":1fu5c02d said:
stang233":1fu5c02d said:

Sherman and our 3rd for leonard Williams and a 1st

Click to expand...

I've been thinking about something like this with the Jets. Probably couldn't pry away Williams unfortunately, but I think they would jump at something involving Sheldon Richardson (they've been trying to trade him because they can't afford to keep him after this year). I know he's only under contract for 1 year but it's at a decent price and we could probably afford to franchise him if we wanted the following year or let him walk and get an additional 3rd round pick or maybe even work out an extension. Adding Richardson to Avril, Bennett, and Clark would probably vault our Defensive line to best in the NFL or close. Maybe even be a better D-line than the 2013 group.

Richardson their 2nd and 3rd - for - Sherman and our 3rd.

If that's truly the market for Sherman I'm shocked. I would have thought it far more. Would the Hawks really get rid of their heart and soul for a guy with that much baggage and that many question marks?

5_Golden_Rings · Apr 10, 2017

I'd take Sherman to the 49ers for a 3rd or 4th, and only that high because the team is implementing a scheme he knows well.

Low balling you say? Well, look at this:

http://socalledfantasyexperts.com/aging ... s-dl-lb-db

The odds are that he's about to go on a huge decline.

NINEster · Apr 10, 2017

I wouldn't worry about Sherman if I was a Hawks fan.

Just get Thomas back and Chancellor firing.....everything will be ok.

Maelstrom787 · Apr 11, 2017

Fletcher Cox and 14 for Sherm, our 2nd, and a comp.

xkj1985x · Apr 11, 2017

Not that the Eagles would ever do this but I believe the Eagles would eat 17.4M in dead cap to trade Cox. Just not a tradeable player until 2019 really.

Sgt. Largent · Apr 11, 2017

irocdave":wm1gtvd8 said:
What if Dallas offers up a premium O lineman, like 2 time all pro left tackle Tyrone Smith and a 2018 draft pick?

Left Tackle > every other position other than QB...........and the Cowboys just locked up Smith to a monster 8 year deal through 2023. No way in hell they trade him.

It's very hard to make trades in the NFL player for player because the cap is so tight, that's why they rarely happen. Unless you can match salary, it's usually for picks.

I've said Tennessee the whole time, they have two 1st rounders. So I could see that happening if Tennessee truly thinks Sherman would help them finally contend for the weak ass AFC South.

So Sherman to Tennessee for a 1st and 3rd, or 1st and 4th. Something like that.

Chapow · Apr 11, 2017

NINEster":qsamb4he said:
I wouldn't worry about Sherman if I was a Hawks fan.

Just get Thomas back and Chancellor firing.....everything will be ok.

Exactly.

The best thing that could happen for our defense IMO is getting Sherm, Earl, and Kam all healthy, rested, and motivated to chase another ring.

I really can't think of a realistic scenario in which getting rid of Sherm makes us better next season.

Chapow · Apr 11, 2017

I'd also just like to add, I think fans way overvalue and are way too enamored with 1st round draft picks (and draft picks in general). There is almost a 50% chance that a 1st round pick doesn't even become a starter in the NFL.

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/20 ... crapshoot/

Sorry, I don't like the idea of trading away an elite player for a complete crapshoot where 50% of the time you don't even get a starter, much less an actual good player.

Sgt. Largent · Apr 11, 2017

Chapow":2uqeg44c said:
I'd also just like to add, I think fans way overvalue and are way too enamored with 1st round draft picks (and draft picks in general). There is almost a 50% chance that a 1st round pick doesn't even become a starter in the NFL.

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/20 ... crapshoot/

Sorry, I don't like the idea of trading away an elite player for a complete crapshoot where 50% of the time you don't even get a starter, much less an actual good player.

Of course, any trade or pick has a chance of not working out.

Just ask the Jets when they let Revis go for a 1st rounder, and drafted Sheldon Richardson, who stinks.

But that's the type of deal that'll happen if this gets done.

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap300000 ... witter_atn

Chapow · Apr 11, 2017

Sgt. Largent":1hnbnjat said:
Chapow":1hnbnjat said:

I'd also just like to add, I think fans way overvalue and are way too enamored with 1st round draft picks (and draft picks in general). There is almost a 50% chance that a 1st round pick doesn't even become a starter in the NFL.

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/20 ... crapshoot/

Sorry, I don't like the idea of trading away an elite player for a complete crapshoot where 50% of the time you don't even get a starter, much less an actual good player.

Click to expand...

Of course, any trade or pick has a chance of not working out.
Eh, I feel like this is minimizing my point. This isn't just a chance of not working out. This is almost a 50% chance of not even getting a starter in return for an elite CB if he is traded for a 1st round pick.The likelihood that pick ever ends up being anywhere near as good as Sherman is right now, is very slim. That, to me, seems not even close to worth it unless the relationship between Sherm and the Seahawks has deteriorated to the point where they just can't or won't work together anymore. I don't believe that's the case.

Just ask the Jets when they let Revis go for a 1st rounder, and drafted Sheldon Richardson, who stinks.
Exactly. Something like that is the most likely scenario should we trade Sherman for a draft pick. Which is why I think it's a terrible idea.

But that's the type of deal that'll happen if this gets done.
I agree. Which is why I really, really hope this doesn't happen.

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap300000 ... witter_atn

Sgt. Largent · Apr 11, 2017

Chapow":lzt5y9ly said:
http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap300000 ... witter_atn

[/quote]

I'd say 99% of the forum doesn't want it to happen.

What we want is Richard to stop acting like a toddler..............but if he can't, which appears to be the case then we have to be ready for this sort of trade, including draft picks.

Because I've yet to see a team part ways with a good non trouble making player on a solid contract, for one that now has a little baggage.

ludakrishna · Apr 14, 2017

irocdave":s3ndpa2c said:
This hasn't happened, may happen, but hasn't. Who would you be OK with in return for a trade with Sherman?

I would like to see #25 stay with the hawks for a couple more years, but it seems it isn't up to us fans.

What if Dallas offers up a premium O lineman, like 2 time all pro left tackle Tyrone Smith and a 2018 draft pick?

Seems like the salary is workable.

http://www.spotrac.com/nfl/dallas-cowbo ... mith-7724/

Dallas is desperate for a corner as well. RS checks every box for Jerry, I can really see this happening with the cowboys.

:lol: :lol: :lol: Oh lord, I can't wait until the regular season. No way in hell would someone trade a perennial All pro LT in his mid 20s for an about to be 30 CB. CB decline exponentially once they hit 30. LTs can be elite well into their mid 30s. Even if we offered our 1st + Sherman for Smith.....Jerry wouldn't accept it.

Bobblehead · Apr 15, 2017

Chapow":3vajl1be said:
I'd also just like to add, I think fans way overvalue and are way too enamored with 1st round draft picks (and draft picks in general). There is almost a 50% chance that a 1st round pick doesn't even become a starter in the NFL.

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/20 ... crapshoot/

Sorry, I don't like the idea of trading away an elite player for a complete crapshoot where 50% of the time you don't even get a starter, much less an actual good player.

Which is why JS is fine for trading our 1st for say players like Havrvin and Graham. well 50 percent of them worked out huh?

Rambitious · Apr 18, 2017

Would you guys do Sherman for Aaron Donald?

DJrmb · Apr 18, 2017

Rambitious":uanhzu2t said:
Would you guys do Sherman for Aaron Donald?

In a heartbeat! But that's probably impossible.

Now maybe just maybe JJ Watt for Sherman would have a chance. It seems Houston is open to moving Watt. They will want a QB most but there were rumblings of Watt for Gronk... They also lost their breakout CB to Jacksonville (AJ Bouye). Probably wouldn't happen but at least both Watt and Sherman are being shopped...

Here's a link to info on Watt being shopped:
https://www.google.com/amp/nflmocks...ns-j-j-watt-emerging-as-giant-trade-bait/amp/

Who would you be OK with trading Sherman for??

New member

New member

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

New member

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Active member

Well-known member

New member

Well-known member

Similar threads