McCarthy turned down an interview with the Cardinals.

Maulbert · Dec 28, 2018

Assuming Wilks is fired.

https://cardswire.usatoday.com/2018..._medium=recirc&utm_campaign=rail-most-popular

I don't like the thought of McCarthy coming back to the NFC West, personally. No matter what you think of him, he does have a track record of success, even if he has a little Andy Reid in him.

Edit- Yeah, this topic is dead.

https://cardswire.usatoday.com/2019...m_medium=recirc&utm_campaign=rail-most-popular

getnasty · Dec 28, 2018

Crazy that Wilks only is gonna get 1 year, there defense has been pretty good all year and it's not his fault there starting a rookie with very little talent on offense.

Polaris · Dec 28, 2018

Consider that Bidwell owns the Arizona Cardinals and is considered to be one of the worst owners in football. Enough said.

Sox-n-Hawks · Dec 28, 2018

It wouldn’t be the worst choice they’ve made. I’d set my eyes on Tomlin though. Assuming he gets fired.

Maulbert · Dec 28, 2018

Sox-n-Hawks":ukijafyu said:
It wouldn’t be the worst choice they’ve made. I’d set my eyes on Tomlin though. Assuming he gets fired.

Pittsburgh hasn't fired a head coach in 50 years (literally). They won't fire Tomlin.

Erebus · Dec 29, 2018

McCarty is over rated. Always got out-coached in big games. I'd welcome him to the NFC West. Just keep Dom Capers away.

West TX Hawk · Dec 30, 2018

Maulbert":2k0pt16s said:
Sox-n-Hawks":2k0pt16s said:

It wouldn’t be the worst choice they’ve made. I’d set my eyes on Tomlin though. Assuming he gets fired.

Click to expand...

Pittsburgh hasn't fired a head coach in 50 years (literally). They won't fire Tomlin.

It's also incredible they've only had 3 coaches in 50 years. You'll likely never see that again in any sport in the future.

As for McCarthy, it would make sense for them, perhaps seeking to redo their offense completely. They need a big splash name to try to ignite their fan base.

Mizak · Dec 30, 2018

He should go to the Browns.

RolandDeschain · Dec 30, 2018

Erebus":1b13lh8r said:
McCarty is over rated. Always got out-coached in big games. I'd welcome him to the NFC West. Just keep Dom Capers away.

You're scared of Dom Capers?

evergreen · Dec 30, 2018

At first I didn’t like the idea. But without Erin he may not be such a success.

Erebus · Jan 1, 2019

RolandDeschain":1hows9me said:
Erebus":1hows9me said:

McCarty is over rated. Always got out-coached in big games. I'd welcome him to the NFC West. Just keep Dom Capers away.

Click to expand...

You're scared of Dom Capers?

Only as a DC. Seems to have Russell Wilson's number.

5_Golden_Rings · Jan 1, 2019

evergreen":20eyhdxv said:
At first I didn’t like the idea. But without Erin he may not be such a success.

He was terrible as the offensive coordinator for Alex Smith.

Maulbert · Jan 1, 2019

5_Golden_Rings":257tufh5 said:
evergreen":257tufh5 said:

At first I didn’t like the idea. But without Erin he may not be such a success.

Click to expand...

He was terrible as the offensive coordinator for Alex Smith.

To be fair, he was only there one season.

RiverDog · Jan 3, 2019

Supposedly McCarthy is talking to the Jets and the Browns, but it would make sense that the Cards would have an interest in him as well. All 3 of those teams are in the same boat, needing a proven QB whisperer for their Top 10 draft pick.

Sgt. Largent · Jan 3, 2019

getnasty":2q9ub144 said:
Crazy that Wilks only is gonna get 1 year, there defense has been pretty good all year and it's not his fault there starting a rookie with very little talent on offense.

I don't get Wilks being fired at all.

I saw last weekend a Cardinals team still playing very hard for their coach, which mean he still has the respect of his team .............AND he had to play a mediocre rookie QB most of the year.

But then Bidwell's one of the biggest bumbling idiots ever to own a pro sports team, so nothing he or the Bidwell family does surprises me.

Maulbert · Jan 3, 2019

Sgt. Largent":fw8q16p6 said:
getnasty":fw8q16p6 said:

Crazy that Wilks only is gonna get 1 year, there defense has been pretty good all year and it's not his fault there starting a rookie with very little talent on offense.

Click to expand...

I don't get Wilks being fired at all.

I saw last weekend a Cardinals team still playing very hard for their coach, which mean he still has the respect of his team .............AND he had to play a mediocre rookie QB most of the year.

But then Bidwell's one of the biggest bumbling idiots ever to own a pro sports team, so nothing he or the Bidwell family does surprises me.

Anyone with half a brain should know that the Cards should have fired Keim instead. The Bidwills are only slightly more competent than Dan Snyder, Jimmy Haslam, and Mike Brown.

Maulbert · Jan 3, 2019

Well, this topic is dead. McCarthy turned down an interview.

https://cardswire.usatoday.com/2019/01/ ... st-popular

RolandDeschain · Jan 3, 2019

Maulbert":1lgsvk21 said:
5_Golden_Rings":1lgsvk21 said:

evergreen":1lgsvk21 said:

At first I didn’t like the idea. But without Erin he may not be such a success.

Click to expand...

He was terrible as the offensive coordinator for Alex Smith.

Click to expand...

To be fair, he was only there one season.

Schotty's been here one season, and managed to get our offense tied for 6th best PPG in the league.

Maulbert · Jan 3, 2019

RolandDeschain":kw9tdcdn said:
Maulbert":kw9tdcdn said:

5_Golden_Rings":kw9tdcdn said:

evergreen":kw9tdcdn said:

At first I didn’t like the idea. But without Erin he may not be such a success.

Click to expand...

He was terrible as the offensive coordinator for Alex Smith.

Click to expand...

To be fair, he was only there one season.

Click to expand...

Schotty's been here one season, and managed to get our offense tied for 6th best PPG in the league.

Yeah, but are you going to tell me the 2005 49ers, who were 4-12 with rookie Alex Smith starting 7 games, Tim Rattay starting 4, Ken Dorsey starting 3, and Cody Pickett starting 2 is as talented as the 2018 Seahawks on offense? Wilson is easily better than those 4 combined. The only real bright spot that Niner team had was their rookie 3rd round pick, a running back by the name Frank Gore. Their best receiver was Brandon Lloyd.

RolandDeschain · Jan 3, 2019

Maulbert":pq49rrzm said:
Yeah, but are you going to tell me the 2005 49ers, who were 4-12 with rookie Alex Smith starting 7 games, Tim Rattay starting 4, Ken Dorsey starting 3, and Cody Pickett starting 2 is as talented as the 2018 Seahawks on offense? Wilson is easily better than those 4 combined. The only real bright spot that Niner team had was their rookie 3rd round pick, a running back by the name Frank Gore. Their best receiver was Brandon Lloyd.

The 2004 49ers scored 16.2 PPG (30th) on offense for the season.
The 2005 49ers scored 14.9 PPG (30th) on offense for the season.
The 2006 49ers scored 18.6 PPG (24th) on offense for the season.

Soooooooooo it stands to reason that McCarthy, if he were worth his salt as an offensive coordinator, would have shown some improvement. Even a little...

McCarthy turned down an interview with the Cardinals.

Well-known member

Well-known member

Active member

Active member

Well-known member

Active member

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Active member

New member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Similar threads