All time Seattle Mariners line-up

I'm sure I can be persuaded several was with this, but here it goes.

1. Ichiro (9)
2. A-Rod (6)
3. Griffey (8)
4. E. Martinez (dh)
5. R. Cano (4)
6. T. Martinez (3)
7. Buhner (7)
8. Seager (5)
9. Wilson (2)

Thoughts? Changes?

Tuh, No Alvaro Espinoza?!

Where is Alvin Davis? Maybe Harold Reynolds.

Def Alvin Davis over Tino Martinez.

Davis and Martinez have pretty comparable numbers... Either of them would be legit... I just know that Tino's swing was so dangerous.

Reynolds is an all time favorite of mine, but Cano has him beat at the plate.

Booney was a beast too... But we all know why #roider lol

Olerud > Tino

Tino had more power but that's about it.

nice thread!

C: Wilson
1b: Alvin Davis (then Tino, then Olerud)
2b: Reynolds (the Boone)
SS: Omar (then anyone else but A-Rod)
3B: Beltre (who else? Blowers?)
RF: Ichiro!
CF: Griffey
LF: Buhner (I moved him to make way for Ichiro)
DH: Edgar

SP (4 man rotation): Felix, Johnson, Langston, Moyer (shout out to Gaylord Perry though)
Closer: Bobby Aya (i just threw up in my mouth).

Nah... has to be Sasaki. Gossage maybe for the one year he was here?

You cant leave ARod out of the all time lineup. You its pretty lame to see the decisions he's made but he raked in Seattle.

KB1999":1d5ldzk1 said:

You cant leave ARod out of the all time lineup. You its pretty lame to see the decisions he's made but he raked in Seattle.

Click to expand...

as a short stop, Vizquel is one of the all time best defensive players in the game (tops the list over Ozzie for some). So I think a case could be had, if we go by position, to choose him over A-Rod.

if you're going 9 best all time, then yeah, ARod would have to be on that list.

Uncle Si":2lvoja2b said:

KB1999":2lvoja2b said:

You cant leave ARod out of the all time lineup. You its pretty lame to see the decisions he's made but he raked in Seattle.

Click to expand...

as a short stop, Vizquel is one of the all time best defensive players in the game (tops the list over Ozzie for some). So I think a case could be had, if we go by position, to choose him over A-Rod.

if you're going 9 best all time, then yeah, ARod would have to be on that list.

Click to expand...

He cheated big time. Who knows where he should be on the list but I have no problem with him being left of the list.

OK... Strictly offense ARod has to be included. Defensively you can't argue with Omar. And I do remember jumping around my living room when I was younger.... M's game on TV... Muted.... Radio blasting Neihaus' call... And screaming Omar hit a grand slam Omar hit a grand slam..... Good times.

ARod belongs on every list.

People need to get over the fact the Ms refused to pay and the Rangers did

I was a big sucker, I kept hoping that Presley would blossom at 3rd but he never did. I also liked Danny Tartabull but not all time. Another honorable mention, Phil Bradley (no real power, but not bad defensively).