If you look around at other NFL teams reversion to the mean plays a huge role. Good teams get pulled downwards due to losing coaches, having poor draft capital and the fixed salary cap, while bad teams get buoyed up by the same factors. The huge underlying randomness in key injuries, key officiating calls, turnovers, and single plays here and there balances out over time and a 10 win team one year may win 6 the next due to nothing but a change in luck.
The Rams went from 13 wins to 9 wins. The 49ers went from 4 wins to 13 wins to 6 wins. The Texans went from 4 wins to 11 wins to 10 wins to 4 wins. The Packers went from 6 wins to 13 wins. For a while there was a trend that at least one division winner would place 4th, and at least one 4th place team would win the division the following year. NFL teams yo-yo up and down by design and they load up on good draft capital and then succeed and are pulled back down by limited draft capital.
At this point in the off-season it looks like the NFC West has four really good teams in it. I don't see the Hawks as more talented on paper than the others and and it's tough for me to see that our expected record should be any better than 9-8.
I understand why people tend to be optimistic. The Hawks have a really good track record of defying expectations and staying good every year, and so at some point expecting them to be a playoff team feels inevitable despite all the adversity. The NFL is rigged against maintaining success, and I think it's more likely that we have a down year or two in the near future than that we continue making the playoffs.
The Rams went from 13 wins to 9 wins. The 49ers went from 4 wins to 13 wins to 6 wins. The Texans went from 4 wins to 11 wins to 10 wins to 4 wins. The Packers went from 6 wins to 13 wins. For a while there was a trend that at least one division winner would place 4th, and at least one 4th place team would win the division the following year. NFL teams yo-yo up and down by design and they load up on good draft capital and then succeed and are pulled back down by limited draft capital.
At this point in the off-season it looks like the NFC West has four really good teams in it. I don't see the Hawks as more talented on paper than the others and and it's tough for me to see that our expected record should be any better than 9-8.
I understand why people tend to be optimistic. The Hawks have a really good track record of defying expectations and staying good every year, and so at some point expecting them to be a playoff team feels inevitable despite all the adversity. The NFL is rigged against maintaining success, and I think it's more likely that we have a down year or two in the near future than that we continue making the playoffs.