Lions plan to attempt to hire GM John Schneider

Maelstrom787

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
11,873
Reaction score
9,687
Location
Delaware
In a truly nightmarish story, nfl.com reports that the Lions are planning to pursue John Schneider - and if they're offering full personnel control to him, they'll be able to legally chase after him under the tampering policy.

One would think that Schneider has been offered full personnel control by many other organizations, presumably ones less hopeless than Detroit, so I don't think he'd really jump ship. Still, the prospect of it happening is sobering.


The Lions began their search for a new general manager with a series of interviews before the regular season ended. But Detroit brass is also plotting a potential blockbuster move.

Sources say the Lions plan to pursue Seahawks GM John Schneider for their vacant GM opening, a hire that would send shockwaves around the NFL.

https://www.nfl.com/news/lions-eye-bloc ... -schneider
 

jammerhawk

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 5, 2007
Messages
10,181
Reaction score
1,787
This would seriously suck! It would mark the end of an era for the team and a team that competed in every personnel situation would be weakened. Make no doubt about it JS is chiefly involved in providing the material for the continuing success of the team.

It’s easy to see why any NFL team would want him especially one that has historically underperformed and made many personnel mistakes, or wishes a proven leader added to their program.

To me though, is there any genuine belief that JS is unhappy here, unappreciated by the ownership, underpaid, or truly working in the shadow of PC? I honestly don’t believe any of the foregoing has application. However, as contractual negotiation gambit or reminder of his true value it is genuine food for thought. I’d also believe there is no way that Jody Allen would want to see JS leave or get outbid for his services.I also suspect his family which has a few real challenges would not wish to relocate and have to deal with any uncertainty.

I doubt that JS has any thought about any of this and is entirely focused upon securing playoff success for his team. Make no doubt this FO is the best ever the team has had and their continuing winning record is proof positive the team has a correct formula and is a place where players want to be. JS is a legitimate personnel wizard and has been brilliant here.

Just so the Nellies Here are addressed, no GM is above making mistakes and JS has made a few, but he constantly works the roster, fixes his mistakes and acknowledges them. He reigns in Pete’s often reckless exuberance, is constantly working the roster, PS, combing the castoff pile for incremental improvements And manages a personnel group that has been way better than average at finding talent.

I think this is a “ cool story Bro” situation and Trader John isn’t likely to be going anywhere.
 

seabowl

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2009
Messages
4,490
Reaction score
1,305
Just curious who is the assistant GM now? Wonder if there has been someone under John that he has trained in case he ever left.
 

ludakrishna

Active member
Joined
May 2, 2009
Messages
1,706
Reaction score
1
Location
Washington DC
Great News. Hopefully it comes true. Scot McCloughan, the real mastermind behind the LOB should be on our shortlist.
 

cymatica

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 25, 2014
Messages
4,387
Reaction score
3,065
ludakrishna":1y7cr3bx said:
Great News. Hopefully it comes true. Scot McCloughan, the real mastermind behind the LOB should be on our shortlist.

Yes ignore everything Scneider has done behind the scenes because your mancrush for McCloughan has you convinced he was solely responsible for the LOB
 

ludakrishna

Active member
Joined
May 2, 2009
Messages
1,706
Reaction score
1
Location
Washington DC
cymatica":gd1i51c4 said:
ludakrishna":gd1i51c4 said:
Great News. Hopefully it comes true. Scot McCloughan, the real mastermind behind the LOB should be on our shortlist.

Yes ignore everything Scneider has done behind the scenes because your mancrush for McCloughan has you convinced he was solely responsible for the LOB

John Schneider is overrated. Only one successful DE picked in the draft (Frank Clark) everyone else has been a bust. Living off of the 2011/2012 draft success for too long. No DB depth since LOB No LBs since Bobby and KJ, no DL outside of Frank. Couldn’t develop a Offensive Tackle in house. Outside of Damien Lewis this year, OL drafting has been terrible. Britt took 3 years to find a role he was somewhat average in. Same is true for Pocic. WR outside of DK and Tyler Lockett have been miserable. TE drafting talent has been horrendous. Reliant on Trades too much. For every Carlos Dunlap fluke trade, there is a Jimmy Graham, Percy Harvin, Sheldon Richardson, Jadeveon Clowney trade to counter it. Go look at his Drafts from 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016...complete joke. Go look at the 2013/2014 drafts. Only 1 player still on an active nfl roster from those draft picks. Add 2015 and that number jumps to 3. 3 players from 3 drafts still on an active NFL roster. Yep, great eye for talent
 

jamescasey1124

Well-known member
Joined
May 4, 2020
Messages
1,188
Reaction score
71
ludakrishna":23qe05he said:
cymatica":23qe05he said:
ludakrishna":23qe05he said:
Great News. Hopefully it comes true. Scot McCloughan, the real mastermind behind the LOB should be on our shortlist.

Yes ignore everything Scneider has done behind the scenes because your mancrush for McCloughan has you convinced he was solely responsible for the LOB

John Schneider is overrated. Only one successful DE picked in the draft (Frank Clark) everyone else has been a bust. Living off of the 2011/2012 draft success for too long. No DB depth since LOB No LBs since Bobby and KJ, no DL outside of Frank. Couldn’t develop a Offensive Tackle in house. Outside of Damien Lewis this year, OL drafting has been terrible. Britt took 3 years to find a role he was somewhat average in. Same is true for Pocic. WR outside of DK and Tyler Lockett have been miserable. TE drafting talent has been horrendous. Reliant on Trades too much. For every Carlos Dunlap fluke trade, there is a Jimmy Graham, Percy Harvin, Sheldon Richardson, Jadeveon Clowney trade to counter it. Go look at his Drafts from 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016...complete joke. Go look at the 2013/2014 drafts. Only 1 player still on an active nfl roster from those draft picks. Add 2015 and that number jumps to 3. 3 players from 3 drafts still on an active NFL roster. Yep, great eye for talent

You are overrated for your posts. Being a general manager is more than just drafts. There is free agency, bargaining, keeping and releasing players, keeping a practice squad and managing the money around all of it
You are basing judgment of said individual around one draft. No one else is.
 

CPHawk

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 30, 2009
Messages
4,931
Reaction score
975
The lions also plan to hire Belichick as HC, sign every top FA, and draft 5 future pro bowlers. They can wish all they want.
 

SantaClaraHawk

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 18, 2015
Messages
15,007
Reaction score
3,088
Florio (who is a lawyer) disputes the nfl media's article as "not nearly that simple" and possibly inaccurate in reference to the nfl.com media report that said:

“Schneider doesn’t have primary authority over all personnel decisions in Seattle — [coach Pete] Carroll does. That hasn’t really mattered, since Carroll and Schneider are in lockstep, but under the NFL’s anti-tampering policy, the Lions or another team could try to interview Schneider if it offered him full control.”

Florio points out that "primary authority" is not the same as "final authority" and says the definition stipulates that "final authority is not a requirement.

He also notes:

At the absolute bare minimum, the situation isn’t nearly as simple and clean as the NFL.com article suggests. Indeed, the Packers sought permission to interview Schneider in 2018 for the G.M. job, and the Seahawks declined. If it was simple enough to offer Schneider final authority over personnel to get him away from the Seahawks, Schneider possibly would be the Packers G.M. right now.

https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2 ... so-simple/
 

Grahamhawker

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 21, 2012
Messages
3,285
Reaction score
382
Location
Graham, WA
Seems like he'd leave on his own terms when he simply wants to. Either this is nothing, or he wants to. I'm guessing it's nothing.
 

xray

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 19, 2018
Messages
9,523
Reaction score
1,584
Location
AZ
Players move on , coaches move on , etc. etc. . That's the way it is .
 

MrFINCH

New member
Joined
Aug 19, 2011
Messages
85
Reaction score
0
ludakrishna":1sp38psk said:
cymatica":1sp38psk said:
ludakrishna":1sp38psk said:
Great News. Hopefully it comes true. Scot McCloughan, the real mastermind behind the LOB should be on our shortlist.

Yes ignore everything Scneider has done behind the scenes because your mancrush for McCloughan has you convinced he was solely responsible for the LOB

John Schneider is overrated. Only one successful DE picked in the draft (Frank Clark) everyone else has been a bust. Living off of the 2011/2012 draft success for too long. No DB depth since LOB No LBs since Bobby and KJ, no DL outside of Frank. Couldn’t develop a Offensive Tackle in house. Outside of Damien Lewis this year, OL drafting has been terrible. Britt took 3 years to find a role he was somewhat average in. Same is true for Pocic. WR outside of DK and Tyler Lockett have been miserable. TE drafting talent has been horrendous. Reliant on Trades too much. For every Carlos Dunlap fluke trade, there is a Jimmy Graham, Percy Harvin, Sheldon Richardson, Jadeveon Clowney trade to counter it. Go look at his Drafts from 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016...complete joke. Go look at the 2013/2014 drafts. Only 1 player still on an active nfl roster from those draft picks. Add 2015 and that number jumps to 3. 3 players from 3 drafts still on an active NFL roster. Yep, great eye for talent

So you’re blaming JS for players that aren’t in the league after almost a decade? I mean man, those trades you mentioned were at the time the envy of everyone.

Tight end drafting talent has been horrendous? So you don’t think Will Dissly has talent? Just gonna blame JS for the injuries?

The EYE for talent is unmistakable as well as his work ethic. Which is why Detroit wants him to fix the whole damn thing.
 

renofox

Well-known member
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
4,218
Reaction score
3,535
Location
Arizona
Doesn't JS still have a year left on his contract with the Seahawks?

If so, the Lions have to pay Seahawks for the trade.

Let him go for five 1st round picks plus five 2nd round picks. He's worth it.
 

Jerhawk

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 22, 2010
Messages
6,231
Reaction score
3,018
Location
Spokane, WA
ludakrishna":uikbhj5s said:
cymatica":uikbhj5s said:
ludakrishna":uikbhj5s said:
Great News. Hopefully it comes true. Scot McCloughan, the real mastermind behind the LOB should be on our shortlist.

Yes ignore everything Scneider has done behind the scenes because your mancrush for McCloughan has you convinced he was solely responsible for the LOB

John Schneider is overrated. Only one successful DE picked in the draft (Frank Clark) everyone else has been a bust. Living off of the 2011/2012 draft success for too long. No DB depth since LOB No LBs since Bobby and KJ, no DL outside of Frank. Couldn’t develop a Offensive Tackle in house. Outside of Damien Lewis this year, OL drafting has been terrible. Britt took 3 years to find a role he was somewhat average in. Same is true for Pocic. WR outside of DK and Tyler Lockett have been miserable. TE drafting talent has been horrendous. Reliant on Trades too much. For every Carlos Dunlap fluke trade, there is a Jimmy Graham, Percy Harvin, Sheldon Richardson, Jadeveon Clowney trade to counter it. Go look at his Drafts from 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016...complete joke. Go look at the 2013/2014 drafts. Only 1 player still on an active nfl roster from those draft picks. Add 2015 and that number jumps to 3. 3 players from 3 drafts still on an active NFL roster. Yep, great eye for talent

What makes the Dunlap trade a "fluke trade"? Curious

"WR out of Lockett and DK have been terrible." So Doug Baldwin doesnt exist anymore? An undrafted rookie that Schneider took a swing on, and knocked it out of the park.

He signed Avril and Bennett.

Jordyn Brooks looks like a fine linebacker.

He drafted Russell Okung, a fine LT who went to get paid elsewhere. He also saw potential in George Fant, but he also left to get paid. He would've got paid here if not for Schneider working the Brown trade.

He's done a fine job as GM, and is able to remain sober unlike McClaughlin
 

misfit

Active member
Joined
Jul 21, 2009
Messages
667
Reaction score
32
Love the fluke trades and every single good move is a "exception" and "getting lucky"
 

Hockey Guy

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 26, 2017
Messages
1,677
Reaction score
930
At least I have identified another poster that I can just scroll by.

You'd think winning in the NFL was easy.
 

toffee

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 9, 2016
Messages
10,601
Reaction score
6,749
Location
SoCal Desert
I think the only authority John does not have at the Hawks is the authority to hire and fire head coach.

Sent from my IN2017 using Tapatalk
 

Donn2390

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 17, 2012
Messages
1,090
Reaction score
878
Location
Riverside, California
ludakrishna":1xolazco said:
Great News. Hopefully it comes true. Scot McCloughan, the real mastermind behind the LOB should be on our shortlist.
There is one in every crowd..! You get more attention posting ridiclous statements than if you go along with the mainstream, logical, and correct thinking.
Someday both PC and JS will be gone and the Hawks will be bottom feeders for a decade or two. Then all of the people badmouthing both over the years, can sit back and remember the good old days. Some don't appreciate what they have, which is the envy of 95% of the league. Maybe 98%......
 
Top