Most Trustworthy (current) Playoff Quarterbacks

[Smellyman]

Romo at #2 is such a joke. Should be

#1 Brady
#2 Flacco
#3 Rodgers
#4 Wilson
#5 Luck
#6 Manning
#7 Romo
#8 Newton

No way Luck should be ahead of Manning

Luck 8 picks in 4 playoff games

 

[kearly]

Tom Brady #4. Did I just read that?

 

[bigskydoc]

Took Manning 6 years to get his first playoff win.

(Strictly a commentary on Luck v Manning, we all know that Wilson has them both beaten in first 3 year stats)

-bsd RPA

 

[Hawknballs]

Seattle's run-first system doesn't require him to do as much as other quarterbacks, and his arm strength is merely average,

uh....he's asked to do more than other QB's. Just not in the pocket.

Merely average arm strength?

So in other words he's never actually watched him play. Makes sense now.

 

[-The Glove-]

Seattle's run-first system doesn't require him to do as much as other quarterbacks, and his arm strength is merely average,

uh....he's asked to do more than other QB's. Just not in the pocket.

Merely average arm strength?

So in other words he's never actually watched him play. Makes sense now.

Sprinting to the right and throwing all the way across the field about 40 yards downfield...I don't think an average arm can do that

 

[kearly]

Didn't Manning go 3-13 or something in his first season? It would be impossible for him to have 3 playoff losses in his first three seasons.

 

[HomerJHawk]

Most Trustworthy? Isn't that part of the Boy Scout law. The answer is: which QB was a Boy Scout.

 

[Seanhawk]

It should be Eli, Russell, Roethlisberger, Flacco, and Brady

Eli didn't make the playoffs and Ben is out. He is ranking the QBs of the 8 remaing teams.

 

[lobohawk]

The arm strength comment shows how uninformed the writer is. It's a lazy throw away line that only reveals ignorance.

 

[12thbrah]

List is bunk. Romo is listed over a bunch of Super Bowl winning QBs.

 

[Hawkfan77]

Took Manning 6 years to get his first playoff win.

(Strictly a commentary on Luck v Manning, we all know that Wilson has them both beaten in first 3 year stats)

-bsd RPA

Is Manning still in his first three years?

This isn't a projection for future production...it's for this year. Luck hasn't proved anything in the playoffs, Manning played in the SB last year and already has a ring.

 

[Seahawk Sailor]

Wow Tony Romo #2 on the list.......Looks like the refs aren't the only people Jerry Jones is paying.

In order to justify that #2 spot, the author kindly asks you to "Forget about Romo's playoff record entering 2014: one win, three losses, a 59.3 percent completion rate, 208 yards per game and a passer rating of 80.8."

Joke article is a joke.

 

[Evil_Shenanigans]

Did Gil Brandt visit a weed shop in Denver before writing this article? Complete garbage!

 

[MizzouHawkGal]

Well of that list at least he has Rodgers, Flacco, Wilson, and Brady right but in no particular order. I struggle to see why Manning, Romo, Newton, or Luck are on the list at all though. Though to be honest Luck does look like he is just about to be deserving of it. Romo probably should be if he does well in Lambeau this Sunday.

 

[bigskydoc]

Didn't Manning go 3-13 or something in his first season? It would be impossible for him to have 3 playoff losses in his first three seasons.

Yes and went 6-10 in year four, the year of the famous "Playoffs? Don't talk about playoffs. Are you kidding me. Playoffs? I'm just hoping we can win a game, another game" quote.

The author of that article/ graphic should have captioned it "Playoff stats in first three post-seasons of their career."

- bsd

 

[bigskydoc]

Is Manning still in his first three years?

This isn't a projection for future production...it's for this year. Luck hasn't proved anything in the playoffs, Manning played in the SB last year and already has a ring.

Just saying that Luck has a place in the convo. He started off stronger than Peyton and is the only one of the two without a losing playoff record. It took Manning six years to get his first playoff win.

- bsd RPA

 

[endzorn]

I don't know about trustworthy, but here's my list of sexiest playoff quarterbacks

1- Cam Newton - I guarantee you there are white housewives all over the country that agree with me.
2- Tom Brady - My girlfriend once told me she would lick his chin dimple. Slut.
3 - Big Russ - We've all seen the magazine cover.
4 - Tony Romo - In an 'Awe shucks' kind of way.
5 - Aaron Rodgers - There are middle aged men licking cheese grease off their fingers and dreaming of him.
6/7/8 - Flacco, Luck, Manning - There are no leaders here.

 

[RunTheBall]

I don't know about trustworthy, but here's my list of sexiest playoff quarterbacks

1- Cam Newton - I guarantee you there are white housewives all over the country that agree with me.
2- Tom Brady - My girlfriend once told me she would lick his chin dimple. Slut.
3 - Big Russ - We've all seen the magazine cover.
4 - Tony Romo - In an 'Awe shucks' kind of way.
5 - Aaron Rodgers - There are middle aged men licking cheese grease off their fingers and dreaming of him.
6/7/8 - Flacco, Luck, Manning - There are no leaders here.

U gay bro?

 

[endzorn]

I don't know about trustworthy, but here's my list of sexiest playoff quarterbacks

1- Cam Newton - I guarantee you there are white housewives all over the country that agree with me.
2- Tom Brady - My girlfriend once told me she would lick his chin dimple. Slut.
3 - Big Russ - We've all seen the magazine cover.
4 - Tony Romo - In an 'Awe shucks' kind of way.
5 - Aaron Rodgers - There are middle aged men licking cheese grease off their fingers and dreaming of him.
6/7/8 - Flacco, Luck, Manning - There are no leaders here.

U gay bro?

No. Wanna meet for drinks to talk about it?

 

[RunTheBall]

I don't know about trustworthy, but here's my list of sexiest playoff quarterbacks

1- Cam Newton - I guarantee you there are white housewives all over the country that agree with me.
2- Tom Brady - My girlfriend once told me she would lick his chin dimple. Slut.
3 - Big Russ - We've all seen the magazine cover.
4 - Tony Romo - In an 'Awe shucks' kind of way.
5 - Aaron Rodgers - There are middle aged men licking cheese grease off their fingers and dreaming of him.
6/7/8 - Flacco, Luck, Manning - There are no leaders here.

U gay bro?

No. Wanna meet for drinks to talk about it?

no thanks