Jacknut16":3pjejcpu said:
-The Glove-":3pjejcpu said:
northseahawk":3pjejcpu said:
The question is, has RW improved at all from 1st year to this year?? I don't see it!
on the other had, Luck is improving year by year in all aspect of the game.
I think that debate can go to rest now.. Luck is a much better qb.
Lol. Am I the first one to call this troll out? Is he supposed to catch all of the dimes he tossed too?
As a Seahawk fan who has been around since day one I have little doubt which Qb will be regarded as the better of the two, but Wilson helped bring us a superbowl and for that Im eternally grateful.
You mean the same Seahawk fan who was constantly putting Rw down, and saying how bad he would be and Cassell was better , and how eve now on other boards never give s a complement to RW without a negative comment. That fan, The same fan who does not pay attention to the facts, Rw has a Qb rating form the pocket over 100 and complt% over 64. He had a bad game, as did the o-line, wrs defense, it happens.
As to Luck and Rw this is the first year Luck is even in the conversation with Rw, and even then he is behind Rw in complt%, td/int rate, qb rating. The only things he is ahead in are by product of attempts. So who is better is still very much in the air, and factually may not be known for some time. I am very sure if Rw had Lucks top 10 pass blocking o-line and top Wr corps and offense built around passing he would put up numbers as good as Lucks, but he does not, yet. By the way Luck and Rw are tied for the most 4th qtr/come from behind wins since they have been in the league. Only difference is Rw plays much tougher competition and usually is not the reason they are behind unlike Luck.
Now let me help everyone out Yes Rw had a bad day. that is a fact, The o-line has had a bad season that is a fact. The wr who have had 7 drops in the last 2 weeks have had a bad few weeks, that is a fact and now our defense is not playing great. It happens.
But really we are heaping this all on Rw who had his first game with a Qb rating under 100 this year. Who had his first game without 2 tds throws this year. Who is still in the top 3 in most hit, hurried and sacked QBS, who has had 7 drops in 2 weeks. Really? I could see it if this is what he had been doing all season, but 1 game really? The thing you need to remember is because he only gets to throw the ball 20-25 times he has less margin for error. If he goes 1-10 and he needs to go 15-15 on his next 15 to get to 64%. If you through the ball 35 times like Luck and you go 1-10 you can go 22 for your next 25 and still get to 65%.
Again he played bad I agree, but it is not like he had much if any help at all. Now for some nothing will matter, they just want to say I told yo uso, despite the facts showing them they are wrong, But for some, really the whole team played bad and we want to just blame the QB and worse now say he is not elite, not a top 5 qb, not a player you can win with. You guys do realize that every QB has games like this, most get more help than RW did today, but all QBs have games like this. Even the supposedly way better Luck who did it in the playoffs and cost his team a win. And he did it despite having a much better oline and WRs and playing a much easier opponent.
So lets be rational Rw had a bad game and as he usually does he will bounce back and have a good one, and probably not have another like this all year, despite the fact he still has 6 game against top defenses, unlike Luck who has 1.