IndyHawk":rha7tiih said:
What really keeps the Saints from us is themselves...Their egos are too high at key positions..Coach/QB and WR/TE..Be damned if they will commit to running the ball ..You won't ever see that ..It's live and die by the pass however fancy ways they find to do it..
This is a great point. It's going to sound like I'm disagreeing with you at first, but read on to the end:
Seattle was a pass happy team in 2010 with Hasselbeck and Bates. As they should have been, the 2010 Seahawks defense was an atrocity. Marshawn Lynch was averaging 3.4 yards per carry, and our OL was one of the worst in the league.
In 2011, the defense and running game both clicked in the 2nd half of the season, and that allowed Seattle to win games with running and defense. You need to have both.
The problem is, building a run game and building a nasty, non-finesse defense is really hard to do. We happen to have one of the most prominent visionaries in NFL history running our team, with some great positional coaches and assistants to help him out. Pete has made it look easy, but the fact is that there are only three defenses like Seattle's in the NFL right now (Seattle, Cincy, Carolina), four if you include a mending 49ers defense, maybe five if you include the Texans. And none of those teams, save the 49ers, have a physical running RB that also posts elite numbers in 2014.
Would the Saints be a better team if they had Brees pass the ball 25 times like Russell Wilson or CK? That seems dubious to me. Obviously that should be the goal, but the Saints don't have the peices. I think Khyri Robinson could be their physical Marshawn Lynch type back, but he's 3rd on their depth chart. And their defense is super-finesse.
Your overall point is correct. If the Saints want to contend seriously in the NFC, they need to get a physical defense and make Robinson as big a part of their gameplan as Brees. But that's of course assuming my high opinion of Robinson proves correct, or that the Saints OL could still run the ball in very obvious run situations. Basically, they still need a lot of changes on that team before they have a good reason to change their identity on offense.
But yeah, Pete only stuck with a Saints type of formula for one season, that first year, when he had to. The Saints should be falling over themselves to copy Seattle's D and physicality, but unfortunately for Saints fans they haven't.