HawkGA":1349ffln said:I must say aside from all of the huba bulu about the play, I'm kind of disappointed Sherm didn't do a better job of actually knocking the ball down. Come on Sherm, you're better than that!
253hawk":2w3fv6bm said:
mikeak":1j3xnigf said:Sorry - the rule is that you have to touch the ball WHILE IN FLIGHT
It should have been a 15 yard penalty. Doesn't mean they didn't miss other calls and it is annoying this gets so much attention, but stop trying to argue that it is not a 15 yard penalty
FlyHawksFly":nt0mbh8s said:White Devil":nt0mbh8s said:mikeak":nt0mbh8s said:Sorry - the rule is that you have to touch the ball WHILE IN FLIGHT
It should have been a 15 yard penalty. Doesn't mean they didn't miss other calls and it is annoying this gets so much attention, but stop trying to argue that it is not a 15 yard penalty
So what happens if it's never kicked? You're saying the holder could just sit there with his finger on the ball waiting for it to be kicked for how long?....forever?
Nobody is allowed to touch the kicker or the holder until the ball is kicked.
That's basically what you're saying.
Technically that ball is live on the ground at the point before it is kicked. No different than diving for a fumble and hitting a player on the way to the ball.
mikeak":3ndgcdvr said:Sorry - the rule is that you have to touch the ball WHILE IN FLIGHT
It should have been a 15 yard penalty. Doesn't mean they didn't miss other calls and it is annoying this gets so much attention, but stop trying to argue that it is not a 15 yard penalty
Giblien":13kyhmws said:253hawk":13kyhmws said:
Gif of the year so far. It felt like we had our 2013 Sherman back last night. Not that he has been bad or anything, just the attitude came through loud and clear in last nights game.
Yep ^.... It's pretty straight forward..Once that ball is snapped, it's live and in play.TXHawk":377o4gvw said:mikeak":377o4gvw said:Sorry - the rule is that you have to touch the ball WHILE IN FLIGHT
It should have been a 15 yard penalty. Doesn't mean they didn't miss other calls and it is annoying this gets so much attention, but stop trying to argue that it is not a 15 yard penalty
The ball is always live on every play from the moment it is snapped until the whistle blows. The claim that Sherman isn't allowed to go after the ball until it's kicked is simply wrong.