Who would you take if you knew what you know now? We always hear about the other two I dont think they give this man enough credit. I was jumping for joy the day we drafted him. I would still go with Wilson what about you?

_________________
The office of Thomas and Chancellor specializing in Defense.

Especially considering we stole him in the third round. I think he has the biggest upside outside RG3.

_________________

Can't go wrong with any of those picks. They're all playing outstanding football. That said, I'd still take Wilson and be perfectly happy with it. And if you factor in the cost - i.e., draft position/picks given up for the player - it's Wilson in a landslide.

_________________
World Champion Seattle Seahawks football. It's an addiction, and there is no cure.

We as Hawk fans have been waiting a long long time for a guy like this. Love his game.

_________________
The office of Thomas and Chancellor specializing in Defense.

Just filed under NO SHIT

_________________
Why is it when I try to come off as a smart ass, the opposite happens? :-(

Seriously though, name one thing those other two QB's do better than Wilson? Other than being tall.

_________________
Legal Notice: Only a very small percentage of the things I do and say can be taken seriously. If ever.

I LOVE Wilson, but what the other two are doing is absolutely ridiculous. I think we'd be about 10-2 with either one of them. Have you watched any of them play? RGIII on Thanksgiving? My goodness. Wow.

_________________
Ummm, no sig to see here, especially not a sig referring to Tarvaris Jackson in any way.

You could win a lot of games with all three of them but I am thankful we have Wilson. I really, really am.

_________________


"We're about to be legendary." - Richard Sherman to the Seahawks sideline in the 3rd quarter of SBXLVIII

Yeah I have watch them all play alot still doesnt change my mind tho. I dont know if Rg3 can hold up dudes a string bean. He is good tho but I dont think he is miles above Luck or Wilson like a lot of people say that he is.

_________________
The office of Thomas and Chancellor specializing in Defense.

All 3 are great but RW is magic.

_________________
Wolf grey all day every day.

I don't understand how anyone considers Luck better than Wilson at this point. The Colts weren't THAT bad last year.

_________________

Russell Wilson led TWO game winning drives today. It's not his fault the defense shit the bed.

_________________
RELEASE THE KRAKEN! (FREE BROWNER!)

I would take Wilson in a heart beat. I wasn't sure when we drafted him, I thought awesome, he'll be a back-up until Flynn leaves or until we trade him for draft picks. When Carroll opened up competition, I thought that was Carroll being Carroll and doing his whole comPete thing, I never thought Wilson had a shot. Watching him in pre-season, I liked what I saw and quickly admitted he could take the starting job, but didn't think he actually would. When he was goven the starting job, I thought great, another year of struggling to win games and another year of missing the playoffs. I have been surprised. I LOVE with a capital LOVE this kid. He is the future here. This offense with anyone else as quarterback just would seem odd.

If this was privileged knowledge, I would take Luck in the first, then Wilson in the second and have a quarterback controversy.

well lets see who gets a ring first that should end it

Meh. Turn on the TV and watch how great Nick Foles looks against Dallas right now. RGIII won't hold up and can't will his teams to wins like Russ...and Luck needs 1000 attempts a game to look decent.

10-2 is a stretch pal. I'd say our record would be worse with those other two.

_________________
posted by

I think all have shown very capable QB skills. All have had signature wins and have shown the ability to lead a team in hostile environments. All that said, I take Luck. I like to have players who fit the physical measurements (Lofa was great, but his size cost him an extended career). Having a good football IQ is also part of the makeup, we all remember Aaron Curry.

It seems this will be an ongoing theme as long as these 3 are starting in the NFL. No one will remember when it is all said and done.

_________________

Leon Washington 2010-2012 Red Bryant 2008-2013 Chris Clemons 2010-2013 Golden Tate 2010-2013
Brandon Browner 2011-2013 Breno Giacomini 2011-2013 - Gone but not forgotten.
Wilson will sign for $18M+ (3/4/2014)

Wilson hands down, his TD/int ratio is better than either Luck or RG3's also.

_________________

"Tracy Porter lost his manhood when Marshawn stiff armed him" some dude on youtube.

I voted for Luck. He's really overachieved but the team has had a lot of reasons to do so. I'd expect a sophomore slump from him just because of the personnel around him. RW has the benefit of a punishing runner and an equally punishing defense. Even though they gave up some passes to BM (remember his 20 catch performance back in Denver?? - He's really good) - they hit the snot out of some players and knocked them silly. If we had Luck, we'd nurture him the same as RW. All things being equal, I'd take Luck, but closely followed (microhairs) by RW.

_________________

I don't know about 10-2 with those other two. I very much doubt that. But I can say that of the top 40 ESPN QBR performances this year, only FOUR resulted in losses and TWO of them were Russell Wilson. So, Russell Wilson should probably be sitting on 9-3 right now. Moreover, last I heard, Football Outsiders had Indy's offensive line and receivers as better than Seattle's, so the claim that Luck is doing it all on his own is arguable. Frankly, I don't buy for a single second that Wilson couldn't do the same things Luck is doing if he were in that situation and throwing the ball 50 times a game, too. Actually, I think he'd do better. Objective pre-draft analysis suggested he could be better. Someone posted this in another thread. It's mind-blowing. Check the rationalizations for why that evidence should be ignored:

http://www.footballoutsiders.com/nfl-dr ... ecast-2012

The rationalizations about why the analysis should be ignored in Wilson's case sound so hollow.

They were 2-14.

_________________
February 2, 2014... the day the dream was finally realized

1.) It's clear as day Nick Foles is WAY WAY behind Luck, RG3 and Wilson.. and really he's way behind Weeden and Tannehill too. So when it comes to third round QB's.. JS and PC definitely picked the right guy

2.) RG3 has been fine since his minor concussion. He doesn't play as reckless as Vick, he's much smarter than him.

3.) at the Luck statement. Such a ridiculous statement. Wilson (Seahawks 8th overall rushing) and RG3 (Redskins 1st overall rushing) have a vastly superior running game at their disposal compared to Luck (Colts 17th overall rushing). So of course Luck is going to throw it more. Way to focus on his completion percentage today though.

Look.. Wilson is really becoming a good QB. Today was his best game to date for a whole number of reasons. But trying to diminish Luck and RG3 is hilarious - all three of them are having great years.

_________________
February 2, 2014... the day the dream was finally realized

all you want...but Luck throws far too many INTs for my taste. And you can look at that Colts 17th ranked rush O as a result of the fact that they're mainly calling plays for Luck to throw all the time. Cause and Effect.

Now, given the fact Luck was the 1st pick, RGIII was the 2nd pick, and Wilson was the #75th pick... We got MUCH more value and bang for the buck, and more $ left to spend improving our team in other areas. I take Wilson 99.999 times out of a 100 over both.

_________________
posted by

This was a poll on ESPN this week:

WOW! Can't believe that poll.

_________________

Luck grow better neckbeard than anybody 'cept the Amish...

When Luck can play all the first 3 quarters like he does the last quarter....he will be incredibly scary.

His TD/INT, His Completion %, His overall QB rating, and finally he has more wins than either of those two.

And Luck just got destroyed by STL.

I just reviewed ESPN's season projections based on games to date.

Luck
3,908 yds 58.8% 25/11 TD/Int 7.07 YPA 87.5 QB Rating

RG3
4,456 yds 60.6% 21/16 TD/Int 7.27 YPA 83.8 QB Rating

Wilson
3,411 yds 63.4% 27/10 TD/Int 8.30 YPA 101.8 QB Rating

Wilson in a pass first offense (and a line to protect) would quickly turn into Drew Brees with legs.

He takes over games like few can.

_________________
SUPER BOWL 48 CHAMPIONS!!!!!!!!

RIP ROAD WOES 12/2/2012

Nick Foles sure is surprising me with his play. I guess Andy Reid didn't do too bad in picking him last year. I think he should remain the Eagles starter but maybe it is just a small sample size?

_________________

Leon Washington 2010-2012 Red Bryant 2008-2013 Chris Clemons 2010-2013 Golden Tate 2010-2013
Brandon Browner 2011-2013 Breno Giacomini 2011-2013 - Gone but not forgotten.
Wilson will sign for $18M+ (3/4/2014)

I'll take Luck just ahead of Wilson but would be happy with either. RGIII is injury prone.

_________________

Wrong answer.

_________________


"We're about to be legendary." - Richard Sherman to the Seahawks sideline in the 3rd quarter of SBXLVIII

I've said it before and I'll say it again.... Neckbeard's got nothing on Russell Wilson. #NoTime2Sleep #GoHawks #BVD

_________________
posted by

So far, to me, Luck is a lot of hype. The kid is good... but our bot Russ has had better stats during their careers and as far as I can see, is the better leader.

_________________
I still get chills when I watch the Beastquake run. "Are you kidding me?!!!"

Luck assaulted an innocent Gatorade cooler during a temper tantrum on the sideline yesterday.

I would take either one, but Wilson is amazing all around. He really doesn't allow the size thing to stop him. His work ethic is unmatched and he doesn't habitually do anything wrong.

The kid was something like 9-12 for 160 or something with the blitz on. That is flat out amazing with the OLine. Luck might be as smart, but not as elusive. I don't think RG3 is even that elusive. Nobody has the combo of skills that RW has. I would take Wilson in any offense.

_________________

Luck barely eeked out the come from behind win against us on his home field, while RW was being hurried and pummeled all day with 3 ol starters out. I'm just not that impressed with Luck. Considering what RW has done, while being the most hurried qb in the league, is amazing. File this in the earth to Captain Obvious category all day long.

_________________
"Size matters not. Look at me. Judge me by my size, do you? Hmm? Hmm. And well you should not." - Yoda