Popeyejones":1555w6km said:
Rodgers is already there.
I think Wilson, Luck, and Cam are perfect for the discussion, though.
Luck? So far he is the only one making the argument for why he shouldn't be in this conversation.
Who is the real Alex Smith? The guy who excelled under Harbaugh or the guy without him?
How about Kaep? Are we seeing who he really is now without Jimmy's guidance?
I look at all the hype around Luck and then his actual performance through 4 years and I am asking the same question. Who is Andrew Luck?
I think at this pount it is pretty safe to say he us not the guy everyone expected and Harbaugh deserves emense credit for making him look like the next coming of Peyton Manning.
Maybe some day it will click for him but the excuses have all but dried up. Many were sold on him before ever taking an NFL snap and most of them are having extreme difficulty realizing that he is as much part of his performance problem as all the excuses he has been shielded by. You are just another example of someone who refuses to believe what your eyes and all the stats are showing you.
Cam I think needs to have more than one good season. He looked elite at many pounts last year but overall his stats weren't in line with his win total. Take away the 5 other pro bowlers on his offense and put him against some tough defenses and lets see how he does then.
I suspect Cam will come back to his previous levels this year with a super bowl hang over and a tougher schedule than last year. If not then I think he belongs in that conversation.