Spencer Ware was my adopt-a-rookie a rookie in 2013. Not only did he have a killer college highlight reel, but in preseason action he showed vision, feel, power, and resiliency that legitimately deserved a degree of comparison to Marshawn Lynch. Unfortunately, for as talented as Ware was, his lack of explosiveness and speed made him a poor fit for Tom Cable, and by year two he was gone, understandably so.
Now he's with the Kansas City Chiefs, and suddenly he looks like the incredible running back I always though he should have been. The reason? The Chiefs scheme is a little different than ours, and a lack of explosiveness at RB isn't a kiss of death in their running game. Team fit and scheme fit MATTERS.
You all probably think I hate Alex Collins. I don't. I hate his fit in a read option offense. He just doesn't have the balance, resiliency, vision, feel, power, or suddenness to thrive in Tom Cable's bar fight system. Now, if you snap the ball under center and put Collins 7 yards deep in the backfield to give him a sprinting start at the handoff and give him a clear lane, he's going to get you a lot of 10-20 yard runs. There are teams in this league that run those plays regularly as a staple of their offense, and for teams like those, Collins is a no-doubter NFL player.
On the flipside, I don't know if Pope is talented enough to make it in this league on talent alone. He's the kind of guy that needs the right team and the right fit, and Seattle was that team. So it's a bit of a lose-lose for both Collins and Pope IMO. Collins would be better elsewhere, and Pope would be better here than in New York.