Thanks for all the compliments, very kind of you all. Totally spaced on KPL's special teams contributions! I think he is a stud covering punts and kick returns.
I disagree that he has been a disappointment. KPL was drafted at the end of the fourth round in a average 2014 draft. I think Seattle wanted a CB at his spot (either Pierre Desir or Keith McGill), but who knows. A key special teams member and serviceable backup is a decent return on investment for a fourth round pick. I was looking at players selected after KPL and the only standout I could find was Aaron Lynch (who had a faster 10 yard split than Bruce Irvin), and Zach Kerr. I am probably overlooking other good players, but those were the only ones I could find.
I struggle with evaluating someone's "desire" to tackle in the NFL. I think most want to and on special teams KPL seems to be capable of laying the wood. I wonder if he just needs a little more of a head start to get to his max power potential. Maybe he needs help with his footwork, I don't know enough about the nuances of football and the linebacker position in particular to be able to solve the problem, but I think we all see the lack of power. When I say power I am talking about his seeming inability (from my observations) to stop a RB consistently or tackle a TE alone.
I just keep asking myself if it would be better to have a guy we know can stop the run instead of a player that will stop some passes.
The always great and insightful Danny Kelly has written an article that has a little to do with what is being discussed. You can find it here
https://theringer.com/the-era-of-positi ... .720th4eym
Thanks for the insights and discussion from everyone I really enjoyed it!