Your Top 5 Seahawk QB's of All-Time?

[Crizilla]

1. Clipboard Jesus
2. T Jack
3. Kitna
4. Senaca Wallace
5. Jerry rice

 

[seahawkfreak]

1. Hass
2. Krieg
3. Wilson
4. Moon
5. Kitna

 

[Maulbert]

1. Wilson (1st SB Win, first league passing title in team history)
2. Hasselbeck (1st Conference Championship, first conference passing title in team history)
3. Krieg (1st Conference Championship Game appearance, first 30 TD pass season in team history)
4. Zorn (played competitively on terrible teams, turned in a winning season in only his 3rd year)
5. Kitna (ended the team's playoff drought)

 

[Heyseed]

Wilson, Hasselbeck, Dilfer, Kitna, Moon

 

[Maulbert]

Wilson, Hasselbeck, Dilfer, Kitna, Moon

You're young, aren't you?

 

[Seahawk772002]

1. Wilson (1st SB Win, first league passing title in team history)
2. Hasselbeck (1st Conference Championship, first conference passing title in team history)
3. Krieg (1st Conference Championship Game appearance, first 30 TD pass season in team history)
4. Zorn (played competitively on terrible teams, turned in a winning season in only his 3rd year)
5. Kitna (ended the team's playoff drought)

You backed your list up with solid facts and logic; am on board with your rankings.

Warren Moon was and is a what if QB for two reasons in my opinion.

1. Today he is very much a Seahawk; you wonder if his Edmonton coach was never hired by the Oilers if his HOF bust would be remembered as a Seahawk not an Oiler. Which leads to question what would have become of Krieg?

2. Have seen his ''Football Life' story on NFL Network, get a kick of him and young son making cookies with skittles mentioning Marshawn.

Another part of story is interview with his ex wife and kids from first marriage. My thoughts; today where Warren may not even make HOF(because not said in story and it should not be) with today's social media and domestic violence issues.

 

[chris98251]

Moon could have been a Seahawk three times, he wanted to be here, nobody thought a Black QB could succeed the first time, he went to Edmonton, the second time, the Seahawks passed on him in F.A. and he went to Houston, I think that was on Knox mostly.

 

[kev007]

:2: fellow 12's!

1) Wilson
2) Hass
3) Krieg
4) Zorn
5) Kitna

Honourable Mention - Moon

:sarcasm_on: No love for the Charlies yet? (Whitehurst & Frye) :sarcasm_off:

Trivia question - we had four starting QB's in '91, who were they?

Kev

 

[TorontoHawk]

Wilson
Hasselbeck
Krieg
Kitna
Moon

(Zorn should be in their somewhere but he was before my time so I'm not putting him in. If I did it would probably be between kreig and kitna)

Is Kitna a typo?

 

[Hawkstorian]

John Friesz was awesome.

 

[Seahawk Sailor]

1. Wilson (1st SB Win, first league passing title in team history)
2. Hasselbeck (1st Conference Championship, first conference passing title in team history)
3. Krieg (1st Conference Championship Game appearance, first 30 TD pass season in team history)
4. Zorn (played competitively on terrible teams, turned in a winning season in only his 3rd year)
5. Kitna (ended the team's playoff drought)

Gotta say this is pretty easily my list too.

- Really, really hard to argue Wilson anywhere but the top slot now.

- Really hard to argue Hasselbeck as second, as Wilson has had to eclipse Hasselbeck almost across the board to get where he is now.

- Hard to argue anyone else over Kreig, the interceptions notwithstanding. He was damned productive, and still holds Seahawks records.

- Hard to argue Kitna (or anyone else over Zorn), as Zorn had to work with not only a defensive-minded club, but an expansion club that did not have the breaks modern expansion clubs have had.

- Could put Moon in the fiver spot, but overall Kitna had a better and longer career with the Seahawks. Warren Moon's Hall of Fame career doesn't make him a great Seahawk any more than Jerry Rice's.

 

[Tech Worlds]

Pretty tough to rank when you have only had a few good ones.

Wilson, Krieg, moon, then the rest.

 

[Seafan]

Wilson (If you don't agree then I assume you hate winning)
Hasselbeck (first franchise superbowl, many franchise records, Starting QB for 10 years out of 40.)
Kreig (First championship game, road playoff win, cool nickname "Mudbone.")
Zorn (Original Franchise QB, Largent's best friend, QB coach for Hasselbeck.)
Mirer (Decent Rookie year, Starter for three plus seaons, Garnered two first round picks upon trade)

Mirer only brought one pick. But it was a good one (Walter Jones).

 

[AVL]

"All times" list should always wait a few more years, at least.

 

[HawKnPeppa]

1. David Green!
2. Charlie 'Jeezus' Whitehurst
3. Jeff George
4. Brady Quinn
5. Brock Huard

I can't list the a true 'top five,' with a straight face, because, as someone else said, there is a ridiculously large drop off after the top two or three.