Is the draft still necessary?

themunn

Well-known member
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
3,948
Reaction score
466
I'd be all for reducing the number of picks available/rounds in the draft to 3 (or maybe even 3.5, giving the non-playoff teams a fourth round pick each year to give a competitive advantage over playoff teams) and increasing the money pool available for the "undrafted" players - making salaries more competitive for those drafted outside of the first 100 or so players.

It would probably work out better for players in the long run too, as teams would be more likely to "reach" for players that they believe will make an immediate impact, whereas at the moment, teams will often draft for the future in the lower rounds and pick up a player that they don't necessarily have a need for, when another team was eyeing them.

An example would be our picking up of 3 RBs - a RB needy team might have been willing to pay more money than us for Collins or Brooks because they intended to play them more often than we might, for example. Getting exposure to gametime increases their value when it comes to second contract time.
 

Uncle Si

Active member
Joined
Mar 3, 2007
Messages
20,596
Reaction score
3
pehawk":2jbzo259 said:
Interesting article from PFT. Lots of valid points. It does seem a bit overkill to have a salary cap, salary floor, rookie pool and a draft.

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/20 ... -an-honor/

Instead of three days of a draft, the NFL would have a second free-agency frenzy — one that could be even more compelling than the veteran version the NFL stages every March. (Remember, the NFL once resisted tooth-and-nail the notion that players should become eligible at any point in their careers to choose their teams.) A true rookie free agency process would be much different from Big Shield’s current preference for Schadenfreude TV, but letting the teams scramble for players could ultimately be better.The NFL has had plenty of P.R. problems in recent years. Decades ago, however, the league laid the foundation for one of the great P.R. maneuvers of all time: Making new players believe it’s an honor to not be able to pick their first employer.


Anyway, thought I'd offer some content outside of Marvin and Popeyejones explaining why Jed's not cheap.


Essentially how the big soccer leagues work in Europe. No draft. Just buy your players...
 

Smellyman

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 8, 2013
Messages
7,135
Reaction score
1,065
Location
Taipei
Sports Hernia":28htiokr said:
chris98251":28htiokr said:
How many guys would be jumping to go to Cleveland or Green Bay? Or San Francisco at the moment, the word is out there from players.
Their problem not ours. 8)

Rainy, isolated Seattle would lose out even today.
 

rideaducati

New member
Joined
Jul 25, 2012
Messages
5,414
Reaction score
0
Smellyman":1ogfhk77 said:
Sports Hernia":1ogfhk77 said:
chris98251":1ogfhk77 said:
How many guys would be jumping to go to Cleveland or Green Bay? Or San Francisco at the moment, the word is out there from players.
Their problem not ours. 8)

Rainy, isolated Seattle would lose out even today.

Until players saw where Paul Allen ranks on the "richest owners in sports" list.
 
Top