SheaD
Member
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2023
- Messages
- 42
- Reaction score
- 70
If that was me instead of Walker, I would have scored a touchdown.
The large majority of us, for sure.
If that was me instead of Walker, I would have scored a touchdown.
The 2nd & 3rd replay clearly shows his ass is on the turf.
Very close but the refs did everything they could to get the Giants back in the game.
Ref-think: Seahawks vs big-city franchise? Better find that lone epidermal hair touching the lone blade of grass, and use million-dollar electronics and AI to find it!
Agreed. Looked like one ref was intent on calling illegal man down field even on run plays if he could!!!He may have been down but I don't see enough proof to overturn the call. If he had been called down in the first place I could see it but he wasn't.
The giants got away with a bunch of cheap shots/late hits out of bounds too that were uncalled. Yet they damn well made sure to call everything on the Seahawks. Flag flag flag flag.
I wanted to think he wasn't down, but the booty hit the ground.
Dude, what Bender said is true, those "rubber pellets" got roiled up from the DEFENDERS elbow, not Walkers.You're the only one then.
I guess those rubber pellets bouncing around where his elbow was don't mean anything.
AffirmativeThe pellets were caused by the defender.
Because their bodies aren't squared and they were rolling?I guess I'm trying to figure out how when the defender wound up flat on his back, that Walker's ass was on his stomach. If the defender has Walked pulled tighht against his body, with his ass right against his stomach, then at what point could his ass have hit the turf? Wouldn't the defender's body be in the way?
The 2nd & 3rd replay clearly shows his ass is on the turf.
Very close but the refs did everything they could to get the Giants back in the game
That's what I saw on the replay, too. It couldn't have come from anything else besides his elbow brushing the ground. The air isn't going to blow a rooster tail like that.You're the only one then.
I guess those rubber pellets bouncing around where his elbow was don't mean anything.
Agree - They must have been seeing that shadow of his elbow, and not contact with his elbow & the turf at all. That should have been a TD, but the zebras were afraid to make the right call.I've watched the play 10 times in a row, up close.
His elbow definitely does not hit the turf. It's on top of the defender's arm. There are no angles that show anything close to his elbow hitting the ground.
His butt kind of almost looked like it hit but as soon as their bodies turn it seems clear that his butt was on the defender's stomach area. If his butt hit the turf, wouldn't he have bounced? Wouldn't there be some sort of visual queue?
At the very least, I do not see definitive evidence to overturn that call.
Doesn't matter, because we destroyed them. Still, though. Gotta wonder what the refs saw that was so definitive.
His butt touched the ground.I've watched the play 10 times in a row, up close.
His elbow definitely does not hit the turf. It's on top of the defender's arm. There are no angles that show anything close to his elbow hitting the ground.
His butt kind of almost looked like it hit but as soon as their bodies turn it seems clear that his butt was on the defender's stomach area. If his butt hit the turf, wouldn't he have bounced? Wouldn't there be some sort of visual queue?
At the very least, I do not see definitive evidence to overturn that call.
Doesn't matter, because we destroyed them. Still, though. Gotta wonder what the refs saw that was so definitive.