I'd definitely rather have consistency at under 50 than the ability to hit from 60. Give Wilson a yard marker to get to so we can kick a game winner and I have faith he can get us there way more often than not. Not knowing if that kick will go through after he gets there is extremely gut wrenching.
Walsh was money under 30 yards, but once he hit 40 he was a dead mess. We need someone that can nail the 40-49 yard field goals at a consistently high rate.
Honestly, I think if we look hard enough we should be able to bring in a few young kickers and find one we can polish up to be successful. I wouldn't even mind using a late round pick on a guy if we think he has the consistency we need.
What we don't need is an inconsistent free agent kicker who will have a higher salary due to vet minimums without the solid leg under 50 yards.