I just don't know what I think of him. I've always had a feeling that he had potential, with no basis for having that opinion. To form a strong opinion, I would need hours and hours to watch tape, that I have to admit to myself I'm never going to get around to watching, so all I can do is try to make educated guesses.
I can't remember seeing an offense as random as ours is. At least in the passing game, it seems like you almost never see the same play twice. All sorts of people make unique plays all over the field. I'm sure Russell has a lot to do with it, being as improvisational as he can be. You see us complete weird corner routes and really deep crossing routes, and delayed TE out routes. Deep routes to Baldwin without knowing how he got to the sideline to begin with. We've even seen a back shoulder fade this year to Kearse. I don't know if it is Bevell being inventive, or just a product of us not being able to get consistent with the simple stuff.
We also have very eclectic personnel. Has the line and lack of receivers that get initial separation prevented us from doing things you would think a young QB with a great running game would do, like slants and pop-passes to the TE? Or does Bevell not know how to make an offense execute these properly? Does Wilson not trust the WR's to win on slant routes? Can he even see the TE? The modern passing game now seems to be seam routes and sit-downs against zone, and we barely use either one. The unique way in which we put up very good numbers just makes everything really cloudy to judge.
I do think we'll learn a lot about Bevell by how he uses Percy. He's finally got that weapon. No excuses now. Percy SHOULD make life a ton easier on Wilson. Man press blitz defense SHOULD result in an almost automatic slant or quick out completion. If it doesn't, something isn't right with either Bevell or Wilson. Percy will be in the backfield some. Are we going to be able to use formations and personnel properly to get mismatches?
I know this is the worst possible answer, but I just don't know if the guy is any good or not. However, if pressed to bet my house on whether the next guy is any better, I would have to put my money on Bevell.