hawknation2015":34ylovuk said:
The best characteristic an OC can have, IMO, is not the ability to surprise an opponent, rather it is the ability to appreciate game flow and to make adjustments that fully exploit every advantage at our disposal. Bevell has too often failed at this, sacrificing true advantages for the novelty of surprise.
This is not about one criticism of one play . . . it is about a consistent and systematic failure in abandoning the running game at inopportune moments and simply failing to put the dagger into the heart of our opponents in the red zone, time and time again.
My excitement about the addition of Graham, for example, is tempered by my concern that Bevell has no idea how to fully exploit the advantages this player brings to the field.
This is a very excellent distillation of the Bevell criticism on this board and I too am concerned Bevell will somehow yank our offensive identity askew when given what should be an advantage in Graham.
To augment the point Fade has been making, what red-zone success we do have that doesn't involve a handoff to Lynch usually involves a DOA pass play with mind-numbing route design and selection that has Russell scrambling for his life and producing a miracle that has zero to do with Bevell and in fact has to overcome his "genius". I still remember Pehawk pointing out a play during the regular season that had like all 3 receivers running routes within 5 yards of each other in the right side of the end zone giving us zero chance to succeed with the actual play call.
A similar thing happened in the NFCC on the 2 pt conversion miracle play to Luke Willson. 3 bodies into routes on the right side of the field just mashed up and given no chance by the defense. Luke Willson, interviewed after the game, says he wasn't even supposed to leak out the backside but he saw Wilson in trouble and said why not. Red zone, and both players involved in the successful conversion are going off-script because Bevell can't design NFL level routes.
To the red zone woes I would add Bevell often enters a game with a crappy game plan. The Superbowl was a classic example. The Patriots came in with a good offensive game plan and had immediate success (with the advantage of some Seahawk injuries). Bevell had nothing against the Patriot D. I was shocked and pleased that he found and actually stuck with the Matthews connection later, and that spoke well of him, but what was he doing in the 2 weeks leading up to the Superbowl that it took him a half to figure something out? This is a common offensive theme in our games.
But the red zone thing is really the meat of the argument. Bevell has been able to behave for stretches, usually after he makes an obvious and costly gaffe that results in Lynch flipping him off and Pete calming down the pitchforks after the game by taking blame and saying that "we" as in the team need to do better sometimes staying with our strengths. Cable shoves Bevell up against a locker and for a time he is in check. But he always drifts back to cutesy, and the worst fear of Pehawk and those pointing this out was that he would do it in the biggest moment and cost us everything. Oops.