Chawker
Well-known member
A finely tuned QB with a high completion rate and good mobility. A ttrue competitor for winning, qualitys that should catch the eye of John and Pete. He should still be on the board with our selection.
Cheers
Cheers
J.J. McCarthy
- Thread starter Chawker
- Start date
SoulfishHawk
Well-known member
Def. a strong QB draft. A first round QB is not a gimme, never has been. Fingers crossed we pick the right one. Paging Carolina right now............ouch
49fansinceBrodie
Active member
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2022
- Messages
- 319
- Reaction score
- 224
The Athletic has him as Seattle's choice in their mock:
The Article
McCarthy is a polarizing prospect. He has all the tools, and NFL coaches will love the intangibles, but evaluators want to see him put the offense on his back and take over games. It’s not that he can’t, it’s that he hasn’t really needed to given Michigan’s play style and schedule.
General manager John Schneider and head coach Pete Carroll see Seattle as a win-now team, but at some point, they will invest in a young quarterback to develop.
The Article
McCarthy is a polarizing prospect. He has all the tools, and NFL coaches will love the intangibles, but evaluators want to see him put the offense on his back and take over games. It’s not that he can’t, it’s that he hasn’t really needed to given Michigan’s play style and schedule.
General manager John Schneider and head coach Pete Carroll see Seattle as a win-now team, but at some point, they will invest in a young quarterback to develop.
CactusJack
Well-known member
I honestly don't see a scenario where McCarthy is a legit 1st rounder. I think there's a better chance that he stays in school for another year.
Scouts will likely view him more as a 3rd-4th round talent when all is said & done.
Scouts will likely view him more as a 3rd-4th round talent when all is said & done.
Last edited:
Hawkinaz
Well-known member
Completely agree
Maelstrom787
Well-known member
The average arm talent severely limits the upside on him. You'd have to project every other trait of his to hit for him to be successful.
Other than that, he looks like he can be developed.
Other than that, he looks like he can be developed.
Ozzy
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2013
- Messages
- 9,301
- Reaction score
- 3,824
I would be shocked if he’s a first rounder.
I'll take that bet!! He isn't lasting to pick #20. Please dude stop the talking to hear yourself talk. Watch some film, and check out stats. He may not have eye poping numbers, check out his completion %, then realize he is QB for maybe the best running team in college. Dude can sling the rock. He isn't a finished product yet either.
GemCity
Well-known member
- Joined
- Mar 20, 2022
- Messages
- 2,664
- Reaction score
- 3,078
I think he’s more deserving but, I’d be surprised if he goes before the 3rd round.
If we can land him there….I’d be happy
If we can land him there….I’d be happy
Ozzy
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2013
- Messages
- 9,301
- Reaction score
- 3,824
No need to get personal. It’s ok if someone doesn’t agree with you on a prospect.
CactusJack
Well-known member
Film12Hawk
Active member
- Joined
- Aug 22, 2023
- Messages
- 116
- Reaction score
- 133
I think J.J. McCarthy fits well with what Pete and John like in their quarterbacks. He plays the position like a point guard as he distributes the ball well, doesn't turn the ball over, and throws for good yardage without having to throw over forty times a game. He has pretty big hands. I know that's something John has mentioned he likes. It's especially helpful in the rain. He's very mature for being only 21 and is highly competitive after being slighted by Ohio State. Even this year in adversity you could see it in how he helped his team rally without Jim Harbaugh. So he definitely has a chip on his shoulder. He has plenty of time to develop into a great NFL player. There's a lot to like about him and I can definitely see a fit there based off of what they liked in Russell Wilson and Alex McGough. (Even if McGough didn't work out.)
He's probably my top QB prospect that I could see us having a realistic shot at getting. It may mean trading up a few spots at this point but I think we're at a place now where it's more viable compared to last year and this year. Michael Penix and Bo Nix as well could possibly fit the bill.
He's probably my top QB prospect that I could see us having a realistic shot at getting. It may mean trading up a few spots at this point but I think we're at a place now where it's more viable compared to last year and this year. Michael Penix and Bo Nix as well could possibly fit the bill.
Last edited:
You are correct, and ill even say everyone is allowed their own opinion. My opinion is no way in this life time McCarthy lasting anywhere near 3-4th rd. Honestly it's just blind ignorance. Either way i'ld be gitty if McCarthy was our QBOTF! Go Hawks!
Maelstrom787
Well-known member
I will say, Harbaugh is a good coach to have a quarterback develop under, and McCarthy operates very well within structure.
I think he could be competent right out of the gate, but you really have to wonder what the ceiling on him is with a lack of raw arm talent. Do you want to take the risk on that profile with a significant pick? Can he take you to a Super Bowl?
I think McCarthy ends up anywhere from middling starter to top-tier backup. There's upside depending on where he goes. Had Purdy not become a skilled operator of that 49ers offense, I'd peg him as a great fit there. The Rams also make a lot of sense.
If I had to make a guess now, I'd say Rams in the second round. Maybe Patriots.
I think he could be competent right out of the gate, but you really have to wonder what the ceiling on him is with a lack of raw arm talent. Do you want to take the risk on that profile with a significant pick? Can he take you to a Super Bowl?
I think McCarthy ends up anywhere from middling starter to top-tier backup. There's upside depending on where he goes. Had Purdy not become a skilled operator of that 49ers offense, I'd peg him as a great fit there. The Rams also make a lot of sense.
If I had to make a guess now, I'd say Rams in the second round. Maybe Patriots.
Maelstrom787
Well-known member
I don't think it's blind ignorance. It's just a projection. He has legitimate question marks relating to his ceiling as a prospect. I don't worry about his floor. He's a winner and leader, and he seems to make good decisions.
Ozzy
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2013
- Messages
- 9,301
- Reaction score
- 3,824
He does interest me because he does seem to have that special quality that a lot of guys don’t have. I hate wording it that way because it sounds goofy lol but he does
Boycie
Well-known member
I'm by no means an expert, but when I watch that highlights reel, his arm strength sticks out to me. He also has all day to make those throws as well which he may not in the NFL, but what do I know?
Ozzy
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2013
- Messages
- 9,301
- Reaction score
- 3,824
I agree, he doesn't seem to have a plus arm but I don't know much either lol
