Russ Willstrong":3p2fcx7b said:
Don't want no craptree on my field. Baldwin runs better routes and catches a higher percentage. Tate has better yac and broken tackles. Both have proven more clutch catches with fewer opportunities IMO. Both make much less $$. I'll fantasize about a new rookie before I dream of a Niner.
RW doesnt force a lot of passes, he doesnt like to throw in tight windows...that doesnt mean our wr's catches arnt contested but it does count for something as far as our guys catch %, and the fewer catch opportunities is a rather petty argument, i dont get why so many people on here think thats indicative that it would translates to better stats. look at baseball, theres a lot of players that start out the season batting 500...does that mean theyre going to bat .500 at the end of the season after 500 more at bats? (the answer is no).
but its the only argument we have to back up our wrs, so i get it. personality/money aside, i dont agree with anyone saying they wouldnt trade anyone not named percy for crabtree.
with that being said, i have no issue with what sherm said, im just glad hes not running our team.