Jaworski's top 32 QB's

QuahHawk

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 12, 2009
Messages
5,642
Reaction score
116
Location
Issaquah, WA
He has only rated 13-32 so far and Wilson isn't listed.

2013 Jaworski QB Rankings
Rank QB QBR
13 Robert Griffin III 71.4
14 Jay Cutler 51.9
15 Tony Romo 62.7
16 Matthew Stafford 58.9
17 Philip Rivers 40.6
18 Cam Newton 54.2
19 Andy Dalton 50.7
20 Alex Smith 70.1
21 Josh Freeman 53.1
22 Sam Bradford 51.6
23 Carson Palmer 44.7
24 Ryan Tannehill 52.3
25 Michael Vick 46.0
26 Brandon Weeden 26.6
27 Christian Ponder 53.8
28 Mark Sanchez 23.4
29 Chad Henne 29.9
30 Kevin Kolb 38.0
31 Jake Locker 48.1
32 Matt Flynn 23.4
 
OP
OP
QuahHawk

QuahHawk

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 12, 2009
Messages
5,642
Reaction score
116
Location
Issaquah, WA
I went ahead an made my own top 32, I though Jaws was off quite a bit towards the bottom

Rank QB QBR
1 A.Rodgers 72.5
2 T. Brady 77.1
3 P.Manning 84.1
4 D.Brees 67.9
5 R.Wilson 69.6
6 A.Luck 65
7 E. Manning 67.4
8 M. Ryan 74.5
9 Robert Griffin III 71.4
10 J.Flacco 46.8
11 B.Rapelisberger 62.8
12 C.Kupperdink 76.8
13 Tony Romo 62.7
14 Philip Rivers 40.6
15 Cam Newton 54.2
16 Matthew Stafford 58.9
17 Jay Cutler 51.9
18 M.Schaub 62.6
19 Andy Dalton 50.7
20 Josh Freeman 53.1
21 Sam Bradford 51.6
22 Michael Vick 46
23 Ryan Tannehill 52.3
24 Alex Smith 70.1
25 Jake Locker 48.1
26 Carson Palmer 44.7
27 Matt Flynn 23.4
28 Christian Ponder 53.8
29 Brandon Weeden 26.6
30 Mark Sanchez 23.4
31 Chad Henne 29.9
32 Kevin Kolb 38
 

Teqneek

New member
Joined
Aug 4, 2011
Messages
280
Reaction score
0
Makes sense. A guy who was handed a team with a solid winning record on a roll who's played nine games and a rookie who threw 18 interceptions. Logical in espns mind. What's new
 

Subzero717

Active member
Joined
Nov 5, 2010
Messages
10,005
Reaction score
14
Location
Is Everything
Teqneek":bc247ahp said:
Makes sense. A guy who was handed a team with a solid winning record on a roll who's played nine games and a rookie who threw 18 interceptions. Logical in espns mind. What's new


If he has RW ahead of Rg3 I'm guessing he will have him ahead of Kaep. I'm just guessing though.
 

rideaducati

New member
Joined
Jul 25, 2012
Messages
5,414
Reaction score
0
I guarantee Kaep won't be ahead of RW on ANYONE'S qb rankings next year at this time.
 

Trenchbroom

New member
Joined
Mar 3, 2007
Messages
2,834
Reaction score
0
Location
Spokangeles
CALIHAWK1":3pxejndd said:
Teqneek":3pxejndd said:
Makes sense. A guy who was handed a team with a solid winning record on a roll who's played nine games and a rookie who threw 18 interceptions. Logical in espns mind. What's new


If he has RW ahead of Rg3 I'm guessing he will have him ahead of Kaep. I'm just guessing though.

That I highly doubt. If Jaws is anything he's a "measurables" guy. Russell is too small to be above CK.
 

therealjohncarlson

Well-known member
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
4,473
Reaction score
315
Wenhawk":xrgu025p said:
I went ahead an made my own top 32, I though Jaws was off quite a bit towards the bottom

Rank QB QBR
1 A.Rodgers 72.5
2 T. Brady 77.1
3 P.Manning 84.1
4 D.Brees 67.9
5 R.Wilson 69.6
6 A.Luck 65
7 E. Manning 67.4
8 M. Ryan 74.5
9 Robert Griffin III 71.4
10 J.Flacco 46.8
11 B.Rapelisberger 62.8
12 C.Kupperdink 76.8
13 Tony Romo 62.7
14 Philip Rivers 40.6
15 Cam Newton 54.2
16 Matthew Stafford 58.9
17 Jay Cutler 51.9
18 M.Schaub 62.6
19 Andy Dalton 50.7
20 Josh Freeman 53.1
21 Sam Bradford 51.6
22 Michael Vick 46
23 Ryan Tannehill 52.3
24 Alex Smith 70.1
25 Jake Locker 48.1
26 Carson Palmer 44.7
27 Matt Flynn 23.4
28 Christian Ponder 53.8
29 Brandon Weeden 26.6
30 Mark Sanchez 23.4
31 Chad Henne 29.9
32 Kevin Kolb 38

IM sorry but lol at Big Ben at 11
 

NinerBuff

New member
Joined
Apr 3, 2013
Messages
288
Reaction score
0
Jaws has always been infatuated with big armed, big QBs... he's never been high on Alex Smith, even when Alex was playing very well.

Just another talking head collecting a paycheck.
 

kearly

New member
Joined
Mar 6, 2007
Messages
15,975
Reaction score
0
Up until he got hurt, RG3 was the best QB in the NFL and a likely MVP candidate. Maybe he regresses this year, but having him outside the top 10 is silly.
 

MizzouHawkGal

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2012
Messages
13,477
Reaction score
846
Location
Kansas City, MO
kearly":1s80m4xs said:
Up until he got hurt, RG3 was the best QB in the NFL and a likely MVP candidate. Maybe he regresses this year, but having him outside the top 10 is silly.
So tired of this opinion given he ran a trick offense and still got injured because of it and beat by Wilson head to head straight up while having homefield advantage in the playoffs.. Because od this he further behind Wilson than even. Kwapernot mark my words. Enough said.
 

Scottemojo

Active member
Joined
Apr 30, 2009
Messages
14,663
Reaction score
1
KCHawkGirl":3j31l95l said:
kearly":3j31l95l said:
Up until he got hurt, RG3 was the best QB in the NFL and a likely MVP candidate. Maybe he regresses this year, but having him outside the top 10 is silly.
So tired of this opinion given he ran a trick offense and still got injured because of it and beat by Wilson head to head straight up while having homefield advantage in the playoffs.. Because od this he further behind Wilson than even. Kwapernot mark my words. Enough said.

You should just go watch all his games. RGIII is the real deal.
 

hawker84

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 10, 2012
Messages
5,603
Reaction score
318
Location
Tri Cities, WA
KCHawkGirl":2maaw2gf said:
kearly":2maaw2gf said:
Up until he got hurt, RG3 was the best QB in the NFL and a likely MVP candidate. Maybe he regresses this year, but having him outside the top 10 is silly.
So tired of this opinion given he ran a trick offense and still got injured because of it and beat by Wilson head to head straight up while having homefield advantage in the playoffs.. Because od this he further behind Wilson than even. Kwapernot mark my words. Enough said.

That trick offense got them into the playoffs, and came out of the gates swinging in our match up.. Keep in mind he played us on one leg and had his team up big at one point.. Don't discredit bob Griffin, he is that good.. I have no problem with anyone putting him ahead of RW at this point, Luck on the other hand, not yet...
 

DTexHawk

New member
Joined
May 1, 2009
Messages
3,924
Reaction score
0
KCHawkGirl":1vtit8l7 said:
kearly":1vtit8l7 said:
Up until he got hurt, RG3 was the best QB in the NFL and a likely MVP candidate. Maybe he regresses this year, but having him outside the top 10 is silly.
So tired of this opinion given he ran a trick offense and still got injured because of it and beat by Wilson head to head straight up while having homefield advantage in the playoffs.. Because od this he further behind Wilson than even. Kwapernot mark my words. Enough said.

I've never understood this argument.

QB's are never on the field against each other.

Lesser QB's on better teams beat better QB's on lesser teams all the time.

And with that said, both should be top-10 QB's for the next decade.
 

Marvin49

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2012
Messages
7,941
Reaction score
351
hawker84":3rx1z1fb said:
KCHawkGirl":3rx1z1fb said:
kearly":3rx1z1fb said:
Up until he got hurt, RG3 was the best QB in the NFL and a likely MVP candidate. Maybe he regresses this year, but having him outside the top 10 is silly.
So tired of this opinion given he ran a trick offense and still got injured because of it and beat by Wilson head to head straight up while having homefield advantage in the playoffs.. Because od this he further behind Wilson than even. Kwapernot mark my words. Enough said.

That trick offense got them into the playoffs, and came out of the gates swinging in our match up.. Keep in mind he played us on one leg and had his team up big at one point.. Don't discredit bob Griffin, he is that good.. I have no problem with anyone putting him ahead of RW at this point, Luck on the other hand, not yet...

Agreed...

...and both Wilson and Kaep ran versions of that exact same offense BTW. So........

Granted, nobody ran it as often as Washington did....but still.

RGIII was hurt coming into the game, hurt it worse early on, and then shredded the thing late.

Not really a fair comparison to a healthy Wilson.
 

RedAlice

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 24, 2012
Messages
5,290
Reaction score
975
Location
Seattle Area
Scottemojo":15oykun1 said:
KCHawkGirl":15oykun1 said:
kearly":15oykun1 said:
Up until he got hurt, RG3 was the best QB in the NFL and a likely MVP candidate. Maybe he regresses this year, but having him outside the top 10 is silly.
So tired of this opinion given he ran a trick offense and still got injured because of it and beat by Wilson head to head straight up while having homefield advantage in the playoffs.. Because od this he further behind Wilson than even. Kwapernot mark my words. Enough said.

You should just go watch all his games. RGIII is the real deal.

Absolutely. I watched his games last year since there was value for the Rams to each game the Skins lost. He is amazing, and just pleasure to watch. I found myself not being able to root against him.

Personally, I hope the Skins do not do well this year. After that, I hope he becomes one of the best QBs we've seen.
 

MizzouHawkGal

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2012
Messages
13,477
Reaction score
846
Location
Kansas City, MO
The thing about this season is we are going to see who's the real deal among the "young 5" no excuses, no pass go this time. I believe RG3 is supremely talented but has to change his approach if he wants his second contract.
 
Top