Marvin49":1ujqyvsx said:hawknation2018":1ujqyvsx said:Marvin49":1ujqyvsx said:hawknation2018":1ujqyvsx said:Foster is Aldon Smith 2.0. Tartt and Witherspoon were replacement level players on the one of the worst defenses in the NFL.
M'Kay.
Were you not one of the worst defenses in the NFL?
M'Kay.
Seahawks D 2010 ( Rookie Years for Kam and Earl): 27th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2011 (Rookie year for Sherman): 9th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2012: 4th Ranked Defense.
Things change. Players develop. Not saying this D will be Seattle and there are guarantees but there is TALENT all over the 49ers D (Foster, Solomon Thomas, Buckner, Witherspoon, Tartt, Colbert). "Replacement level players". LOL. Yer funny.
I realize you are just trolling for a reaction, but man...you gotta try harder.
SF49r":3oj1yn3j said:He just making himself look stupid for when we grave dig this thread 6 months from now
SF49r":2qjivrr7 said:And I could care less about your input on my team.. thanks
Don't rank defenses by yardage. Ignorant metric.Marvin49":2lbmo9me said:Seahawks D 2010 ( Rookie Years for Kam and Earl): 27th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2011 (Rookie year for Sherman): 9th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2012: 4th Ranked Defense.
RolandDeschain":3q5rwvlb said:Don't rank defenses by yardage. Ignorant metric.Marvin49":3q5rwvlb said:Seahawks D 2010 ( Rookie Years for Kam and Earl): 27th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2011 (Rookie year for Sherman): 9th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2012: 4th Ranked Defense.
The 49ers defense was that bad because the offense was horrid (specifically the qbs, guards and rt). Look at what the defense did after the offense started converting third downs (when Jimmy G began to start).adeltaY":xmthsrgp said:Marvin49":xmthsrgp said:hawknation2018":xmthsrgp said:Marvin49":xmthsrgp said:M'Kay.
Were you not one of the worst defenses in the NFL?
M'Kay.
Seahawks D 2010 ( Rookie Years for Kam and Earl): 27th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2011 (Rookie year for Sherman): 9th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2012: 4th Ranked Defense.
Things change. Players develop. Not saying this D will be Seattle and there are guarantees but there is TALENT all over the 49ers D (Foster, Solomon Thomas, Buckner, Witherspoon, Tartt, Colbert). "Replacement level players". LOL. Yer funny.
I realize you are just trolling for a reaction, but man...you gotta try harder.
Forgot about Thomas. Vast majority of even top pick DL players take a while to develop so he will continue to get better.
Not sure what we have to gain by denying good players on bad defenses their due. Aren't we hoping our own players develop and that's why it's okay that we lost so much defensive talent? Would niners fans be correct in saying Shaquill Griffin is a slightly above average player because our defense finished slightly above average (13th)? Can't have it both ways.
Marvin49":j5anqq13 said:RolandDeschain":j5anqq13 said:Don't rank defenses by yardage. Ignorant metric.Marvin49":j5anqq13 said:Seahawks D 2010 ( Rookie Years for Kam and Earl): 27th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2011 (Rookie year for Sherman): 9th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2012: 4th Ranked Defense.
So if you use Pts its 2010: 25th, 2011: 7th, 2012: 1st.
...which doesn't in any way change point I was making. Players improve. Things change.
By his logic Kam and Earl suck because they had the 25th ranked D in 2010.
Clearly, that's not the case.
hawknation2018":2a8z7m6y said:Marvin49":2a8z7m6y said:RolandDeschain":2a8z7m6y said:Don't rank defenses by yardage. Ignorant metric.Marvin49":2a8z7m6y said:Seahawks D 2010 ( Rookie Years for Kam and Earl): 27th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2011 (Rookie year for Sherman): 9th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2012: 4th Ranked Defense.
So if you use Pts its 2010: 25th, 2011: 7th, 2012: 1st.
...which doesn't in any way change point I was making. Players improve. Things change.
By his logic Kam and Earl suck because they had the 25th ranked D in 2010.
Clearly, that's not the case.
Things change.
Ipso facto, the Whiner defense will go from crap to great this year.
Amazing argument, Baghdad Bob.
hawknation2018":1hzo7z08 said:The topic is a prediction thread.
Man up and give one.
RolandDeschain":198d5hjf said:Don't rank defenses by yardage. Ignorant metric.Marvin49":198d5hjf said:Seahawks D 2010 ( Rookie Years for Kam and Earl): 27th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2011 (Rookie year for Sherman): 9th Ranked Defense
Seahawks D 2012: 4th Ranked Defense.
Maulbert":1keyv4sb said: