RationalNiner":3mcifryw said:
I'd call RW top 5 at this point, which is actually a huge compliment for someone with only 2 seasons as a starter.
All the big names are better QBs, Brady, Manning, Brees, ARod and as unpopular as this might sound Roethlisraper IMHO.
Not just from stats, but from the ability to extend plays and make all the throws.
RW can make all the throws, the burner, the deep ball, the fade, the sideline and while on the run in either direction. At this point it is just a matter of experience.
Part of me wants to put Rivers ahead of RW also, Ryan fits in that area too. I would say top 10 for sure and for 3rd year, that is still saying something.
What we do know is that RW is no fluke. A certain group of fans on a rival board claim he will be exposed as some fraud, but they have made that claim all 3 years and he has only improved.
CK is a little behind him in 3-4 areas, keeping a cool head, pocket elusiveness, taking mojo off the ball and seeing his options. But he also has a little more arm, better break away speed and height.
If Stafford wasn't a pick machine, he would be SO dangerous.