HawkGA":24d9weq7 said:So they should stop letting the best teams in? Yep, that sounds like a PAC-12 fan.
JSeahawks":184igsmi said:HawkGA":184igsmi said:So they should stop letting the best teams in? Yep, that sounds like a PAC-12 fan.
Think you misread my post, actually I’m saying they SHOULD put the 4 best teams in, not the 4 teams with the best records.Even if they’re all from the sec and have a couple losses. Sure Notre Dame was undefeated, but is there anybody who actually thought they were one of the 4 best teams?
ivotuk":2ugbmkcp said:JSeahawks":2ugbmkcp said:HawkGA":2ugbmkcp said:So they should stop letting the best teams in? Yep, that sounds like a PAC-12 fan.
Think you misread my post, actually I’m saying they SHOULD put the 4 best teams in, not the 4 teams with the best records.Even if they’re all from the sec and have a couple losses. Sure Notre Dame was undefeated, but is there anybody who actually thought they were one of the 4 best teams?
Weird thing is, I read it the same way as HawkGA read it. Maybe it needs a comma somewhere? Or grammar correcting?
Anybody else read that post as "keeping those 4 teams out?"
HawkGA":1gm5dkxb said:ivotuk":1gm5dkxb said:JSeahawks":1gm5dkxb said:HawkGA":1gm5dkxb said:So they should stop letting the best teams in? Yep, that sounds like a PAC-12 fan.
Think you misread my post, actually I’m saying they SHOULD put the 4 best teams in, not the 4 teams with the best records.Even if they’re all from the sec and have a couple losses. Sure Notre Dame was undefeated, but is there anybody who actually thought they were one of the 4 best teams?
Weird thing is, I read it the same way as HawkGA read it. Maybe it needs a comma somewhere? Or grammar correcting?
Anybody else read that post as "keeping those 4 teams out?"
Somebody get iRo in here for an edit!
I don't know that Notre Dame is one of the 4 best, but I'm not sure who I would replace them with. Georgia is darn good, but 2 losses and having just lost to Alabama on a neutral field, I don't think they should have gotten in. Ohio State? Meh. Maybe. Ultimately, I don't have a problem with Notre Dame getting in because I just don't know a clear cut better alternative.
Milehighhawk":240sfmpx said:I can’t see how anyone can say they enjoyed watching those games. NCAAF is the most unbalanced and non competitive league in all of sport I think with the NBA a close second. The model is clearly broken. Not sure how long a league can go on with allowing a handful of schools to choose from the very best players.
This actually reminds me of stacked little league teams that play down a couple levels to warm up for their “real season”. It is pretty much antithetical to the concept of sport.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
West TX Hawk":23ezio16 said:To prevent these continuously awful semifinal games, they need to expand to 8 teams in the playoff. I stated this premise before, but one of the reasons is teams like ND and OU would be eliminated in the 1st round and quality teams like Georgia and OH St would likely win so you would truly have the best 4 teams and much better matchups in the semis and final.
ND may have been undefeated but their talent level is nowhere near Georgia's. You expand to 8, the best will prevail.