Missing_Clink":2dg2ck8r said:Only if it is for dirt cheap. Sid was a shell of himself last season, and that was BEFORE he tore his ACL. The Witch Doctor treatments in Europe didn't seem to help him, and he was not the Sid we had known. I think he may be done but doesn't hurt to give him 1 more chance if the price is right.
Good points, and I agree for the most part, except for the Arizona game. Russell was hung over that day and it was impossible for us to win unless we got a pic 6.CALIHAWK1":31xaeoln said:Missing_Clink":31xaeoln said:Only if it is for dirt cheap. Sid was a shell of himself last season, and that was BEFORE he tore his ACL. The Witch Doctor treatments in Europe didn't seem to help him, and he was not the Sid we had known. I think he may be done but doesn't hurt to give him 1 more chance if the price is right.
I disagree. He was a product of our offense. It seemed every game he made a huge tip toe first down. I also strongly believe that had he and Harvin been healthy all year (big hypothetical) I dont think we would have lost a game.
MysterMatt":2nhj1i1d said:Good points, and I agree for the most part, except for the Arizona game. Russell was hung over that day and it was impossible for us to win unless we got a pic 6.CALIHAWK1":2nhj1i1d said:Missing_Clink":2nhj1i1d said:Only if it is for dirt cheap. Sid was a shell of himself last season, and that was BEFORE he tore his ACL. The Witch Doctor treatments in Europe didn't seem to help him, and he was not the Sid we had known. I think he may be done but doesn't hurt to give him 1 more chance if the price is right.
I disagree. He was a product of our offense. It seemed every game he made a huge tip toe first down. I also strongly believe that had he and Harvin been healthy all year (big hypothetical) I dont think we would have lost a game.
CALIHAWK1":3025aoxq said:Missing_Clink":3025aoxq said:Only if it is for dirt cheap. Sid was a shell of himself last season, and that was BEFORE he tore his ACL. The Witch Doctor treatments in Europe didn't seem to help him, and he was not the Sid we had known. I think he may be done but doesn't hurt to give him 1 more chance if the price is right.
I disagree. He was a product of our offense. It seemed every game he made a huge tip toe first down. I also strongly believe that had he and Harvin been healthy all year (big hypothetical) I dont think we would have lost a game.
DavidSeven":1gbnh0fp said:We get it, guys. He falls after catching a lot. I think 30 different posters making that exact same one sentence comment has conveyed that point sufficiently.
If the price is right....just like his contract.YYZHawksFan":3ec2zd9e said:ha...so who hedges their bets and picks up a rice elite jersey at a discount... ;-0)